CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.House Bill 3081
Florida House of Representatives - 1998 HB 3081
By Representative Casey
1 A bill to be entitled
2 An act relating to Alachua County; providing
3 for the relief of Matthew White; providing for
4 an appropriation to compensate him for injuries
5 and damages sustained as a result of the
6 negligence of the Alachua County Sheriff's
7 Department; providing an effective date.
8
9 WHEREAS, on November 5, 1988, at approximately 4:00
10 a.m., Matthew White was injured when his motorcycle struck a
11 horse that was being chased at night by a City of Waldo police
12 officer, and
13 WHEREAS, the City of Waldo police officer had been
14 dispatched by the Alachua County Sheriff's Department to a
15 location in Alachua County to investigate and "handle" a CB
16 radio report that there was a horse loose on U.S. Highway 301
17 north of Waldo, and
18 WHEREAS, a civilian passerby who was attempting to
19 assist the City of Waldo police officer described the events
20 leading up to the accident as a "lights-off sneak attack" on
21 the horse in the median of the divided highway, and
22 WHEREAS, the City of Waldo police officer driving the
23 police cruiser, with the civilian witness seated on the hood
24 of the police cruiser, eased up to the horse, which they had
25 been chasing for nearly a mile, back and forth across Highway
26 301, in an attempt to secure the horse by the civilian
27 attempting to place his arms around the neck of the horse, and
28 WHEREAS, this attempt to secure the horse was taking
29 place as Matthew White approached the area on his motorcycle,
30 and
31
1
CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
Florida House of Representatives - 1998 HB 3081
529-165A-98
1 WHEREAS, this method of attempting to secure the horse
2 spooked the horse one final time, causing the horse to run out
3 into the highway and into the motorcycle traveling north
4 within the lawful speed limit, operated by Lieutenant Matthew
5 White, a Florida National Guard Officer and a student at the
6 University of Florida, and
7 WHEREAS, the City of Waldo police officer had turned
8 off the blue lights, headlights, and flashers on the police
9 cruiser, and
10 WHEREAS, upon impact with the horse, Matthew White was
11 thrown over 100 feet from the motorcycle he was operating and
12 landed in a ditch, and
13 WHEREAS, Matthew White sustained complete, or nearly
14 complete, tears of all four of the ligaments that hold the
15 lower leg to the upper leg at the knee, and
16 WHEREAS, Dr. McFarland, the orthopedist at Shands
17 Teaching Hospital, testified that it would not have been
18 uncommon for Matthew White to have lost his leg as a result of
19 the injuries he sustained, and
20 WHEREAS, Dr. McFarland and his staff were able to
21 reattach the torn ligaments in Matthew White's leg over the
22 course of a year of surgery, and
23 WHEREAS, with subsequent surgical procedures, Matthew
24 White was eventually able to regain some use of his leg, and
25 WHEREAS, Matthew White received a 20 percent permanent
26 impairment from Dr. McFarland, however, his leg was so
27 impaired that he was within 1 percentage point of the degree
28 of impairment which would require mandatory medical discharge
29 from the United States Army, and
30 WHEREAS, Matthew White's goal in life was to serve as a
31 full-time active duty military officer, and
2
CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
Florida House of Representatives - 1998 HB 3081
529-165A-98
1 WHEREAS, Matthew White attended the Georgia Military
2 Academy for 2 years, and
3 WHEREAS, following his attendance at Georgia Military
4 Academy, Matthew White received an early commission as a
5 Second Lieutenant in the United States Army, and
6 WHEREAS, the program required him to serve in a
7 National Guard or Army Reserve troop unit during the last 2
8 years of his college enrollment so that he could enter federal
9 active duty upon graduation, and
10 WHEREAS, the accident of November 5, 1988, the injuries
11 sustained by Matthew White as a result of the accident, and
12 the recuperation from those injuries put Matthew White
13 seriously behind in his obligation to complete college within
14 that time period, and to receive his Officer's Basic Training,
15 and
16 WHEREAS, Matthew White was medically disabled for a
17 year and a half following the accident, and was finally called
18 to active duty for his Officer's Basic Training Course as a
19 result of Operation Desert Storm, and
20 WHEREAS, Matthew White was rejected for active duty
21 following Desert Storm and the completion of his Engineer
22 Officer Basic Course, and
23 WHEREAS, the ROTC Senior Military Instructor who was
24 called as an expert witness in this case stated that Matthew
25 White effectively lost his opportunity to compete as an
26 Engineer Officer in the United States Army in both the active
27 component and the reserve component, and
28 WHEREAS, Matthew White is now discharged from the
29 United States Army, and
30
31
3
CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
Florida House of Representatives - 1998 HB 3081
529-165A-98
1 WHEREAS, as a result of the accident of November 5,
2 1988, Matthew White sustained serious injury that formed the
3 basis of legal action brought by Matthew White, and
4 WHEREAS, following trial on this matter, a judgment was
5 returned by the jury in the amount of $489,942.65, and
6 WHEREAS, a subsequent award for costs and the amount of
7 the judgment was entered in the amount of $501,116.19, and
8 WHEREAS, a total of $55,000 was paid from Florida Risk
9 Management toward the settlement, and $45,000 has been paid on
10 behalf of the City of Waldo in settlement of the claim prior
11 to the trial in this action, and
12 WHEREAS, the verdict returned by the jury assessed 100
13 percent liability for the accident upon the Alachua County
14 Sheriff's Department, and
15 WHEREAS, there remains due and unpaid the sum of
16 $401,116.19, NOW, THEREFORE,
17
18 Be It Enacted by the Legislature of the State of Florida:
19
20 Section 1. The facts stated in the preamble to this
21 act are found and declared to be true.
22 Section 2. The Alachua County Sheriff's Department is
23 authorized and directed to appropriate from funds of the
24 sheriff's department not otherwise appropriated and to draw a
25 warrant in the sum of $401,116.19 payable to Matthew White as
26 compensation for injuries and damages sustained due to the
27 negligence of the Alachua County Sheriff's Department.
28 Section 3. This act shall take effect upon becoming a
29 law.
30
31
4