CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.House Bill 0895
Florida House of Representatives - 1997 HB 895
By Representatives Dawson-White, Lippman, Casey, Thrasher,
Miller, Jones, Healey, Arnall and Peaden
1 A bill to be entitled
2 An act relating to trauma centers; amending s.
3 395.402, F.S.; providing legislative
4 recognition of pediatric trauma referral
5 centers; providing legislative intent regarding
6 factors to be considered in devising planning
7 guidelines; prescribing the number and types of
8 patients to be treated at pediatric trauma
9 referral centers; amending s. 395.4025, F.S.;
10 providing for the selection of state-approved
11 trauma centers and pediatric trauma referral
12 centers; amending procedures for renewing
13 verification; requiring the formation of a task
14 force on pediatric trauma; providing for
15 membership, duties, and responsibilities of the
16 task force members; requiring a report to the
17 Legislature; providing for the inapplicability
18 of this act to certain pending cases; providing
19 an effective date.
20
21 Be It Enacted by the Legislature of the State of Florida:
22
23 Section 1. Subsections (1) and (2) of section 395.402,
24 Florida Statutes, are amended, present subsection (3) of that
25 section is renumbered as subsection (4), and a new subsection
26 (3) is added to that section, to read:
27 395.402 Trauma service areas; number and location of
28 trauma centers.--
29 (1) The Legislature finds that it is appropriate to
30 recognize as a trauma patient someone with an injury severity
31 score (ISS) of 9 or greater. The Legislature also recognizes
1
CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
Florida House of Representatives - 1997 HB 895
507-149-97
1 that Level I and Level II trauma centers and pediatric trauma
2 referral centers should each be capable of annually treating a
3 minimum of 1,000, and 500, and 150 patients, respectively,
4 with an injury severity score of 9 or greater. Further, the
5 Legislature finds that, based on the numbers and locations of
6 trauma victims with these injury severity scores, there should
7 be 19 trauma service areas in the state, and, at a minimum,
8 there should be at least one trauma center in each service
9 area.
10 (2) It is the intent of the Legislature that, as a
11 planning guideline, Level I and Level II trauma centers and
12 pediatric trauma referral centers should generally each
13 provide care annually to approximately a minimum of 1,000, and
14 500, and 150 patients, respectively, as provided in subsection
15 (1). It is the further intent of the Legislature that, as a
16 planning guideline, factors such as geography, relative
17 population density, and other factors that ensure access to
18 trauma care may be considered. Level II trauma centers in
19 counties of more than 500,000 population are expected to be
20 able to care for 1,000 patients per year, as a planning
21 guideline.
22 (3) For purposes of subsections (1) and (2), adult
23 patients who are treated at a Level I or Level II trauma
24 center may not be considered to be pediatric trauma patients.
25 Section 2. Subsections (1), (2), (4), and (6) of
26 section 395.4025, Florida Statutes, 1996 Supplement, are
27 amended to read:
28 395.4025 Selection of state-approved trauma centers.--
29 (1) For purposes of developing a system of
30 state-approved trauma centers, the department shall use the 19
31 trauma service areas established in s. 395.402. Within each
2
CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
Florida House of Representatives - 1997 HB 895
507-149-97
1 service area and based on the state trauma system plan, the
2 local or regional trauma services system plan, recommendations
3 of the local or regional trauma agency, and the 1990 Report
4 and Proposal for Funding State-Sponsored Trauma Centers, the
5 department shall establish the approximate number of
6 state-approved trauma centers needed to ensure reasonable
7 access to high-quality trauma services. Using the guidelines
8 and procedures outlined in the 1990 report, except when in
9 conflict with those prescribed in this section, or when in
10 conflict with the local or regional trauma agency plan as
11 approved by the department, the department shall select those
12 hospitals that are to be recognized as state-approved trauma
13 centers and shall include all trauma centers verified as of
14 October 1, 1990, and subsequently, subject to specific
15 programmatic and quality of care standards.
16 (2)(a) The department shall annually notify each acute
17 care general hospital and each local and each regional trauma
18 agency in the state that the department is accepting letters
19 of intent from hospitals that are interested in becoming
20 state-approved trauma centers. In order to be considered by
21 the department, a hospital that operates within the geographic
22 area of a local or regional trauma agency must submit written
23 certification by the local or regional trauma agency that the
24 verification of the hospital as a Level I or Level II trauma
25 center or as a pediatric trauma referral center together with
26 its letter of intent certify that its intent to operate as a
27 state-approved trauma center is consistent with the trauma
28 services plan of the local or regional trauma agency, as
29 approved by the department, if such agency exists. Letters of
30 intent must be submitted to the department and to the local or
31 regional trauma agency, if one exists, and must be postmarked
3
CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
Florida House of Representatives - 1997 HB 895
507-149-97
1 no later than midnight October 1 of the year in which the
2 letter of intent is filed. The department may not consider the
3 letter of intent or application of any hospital that has not
4 timely filed both a letter of intent and a written
5 confirmation of consistency with the local or regional agency
6 plan as required by this section. This paragraph does not
7 apply to any hospital that is a provisional or verified trauma
8 center on January 1, 1992.
9 (b) By October 15, the department shall send to all
10 hospitals that submitted a letter of intent an application
11 package that will provide the hospitals with instructions for
12 submitting information to the department for selection as a
13 state-approved trauma center. The standards for verification
14 of trauma centers and pediatric trauma referral centers
15 provided for in s. 395.401(3), as adopted by rule of the
16 department, shall serve as the basis for these instructions.
17 (c) In order to be considered by the department,
18 applications from those hospitals seeking selection as
19 state-approved trauma centers or state-approved pediatric
20 trauma referral centers, including those current verified
21 trauma centers that seek to be state-approved trauma centers
22 or state-approved pediatric trauma referral centers, must be
23 received by the department and, for any hospital that operates
24 within the geographic area of a local or regional trauma
25 agency, by the local or regional trauma agency, no later than
26 the close of business on April 1. The department shall conduct
27 a provisional review of each application for the purpose of
28 determining that the hospital's application is complete and
29 that the hospital has the critical elements required for a
30 state-approved trauma center. The local or regional trauma
31 agency shall conduct a preliminary review of the application
4
CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
Florida House of Representatives - 1997 HB 895
507-149-97
1 for the purposes of this paragraph and shall submit comments
2 or recommendations to the department no later than the close
3 of business on April 7. In reviewing the application, the
4 department shall consider the comments or recommendations
5 submitted by the local or regional trauma agency. If the
6 department makes a finding of fact or determination regarding
7 the application which is counter to the comments or
8 recommendations submitted by the local or regional trauma
9 agency, the department must provide to the local or regional
10 trauma agency, in writing, its reasons for its findings, item
11 by item. This critical review conducted by the department and
12 by the local or regional trauma agency must will be based on
13 trauma center verification standards and must shall include,
14 but is not be limited to, a review of whether the hospital
15 has:
16 1. Equipment and physical facilities necessary to
17 provide trauma services.
18 2. Personnel in sufficient numbers and with proper
19 qualifications to provide trauma services.
20 3. An effective quality assurance process.
21 4. Submitted written confirmation by the local or
22 regional trauma agency that the verification of the hospital
23 as a state-approved trauma center is consistent with the plan
24 of the local or regional trauma agency, as approved by the
25 department, if such agency exists. This subparagraph applies
26 to any hospital that is not a provisional or verified trauma
27 center on January 1, 1992.
28
29 Any application that is submitted by a hospital that has
30 failed to comply with the requirements of paragraph (2)(a)
31
5
CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
Florida House of Representatives - 1997 HB 895
507-149-97
1 must be rejected and may not be considered by the department
2 or by the local or regional trauma agency.
3 (d)1. Notwithstanding other provisions in this
4 section, the department may grant up to an additional 18
5 months to a hospital applicant that is unable to meet all
6 requirements as provided in paragraph (c) at the time of
7 application if the number of applicants in the service area in
8 which the applicant is located is equal to or less than the
9 service area allocation, as provided by rule of the
10 department. An applicant that is granted additional time
11 pursuant to this paragraph shall submit a plan for
12 departmental approval which includes timelines and activities
13 that the applicant proposes to complete in order to meet
14 application requirements. Any applicant that demonstrates an
15 ongoing effort to complete the activities within the timelines
16 outlined in the plan shall be included in the number of
17 state-approved trauma centers at such time that the department
18 has conducted a provisional review of the application and has
19 determined that the application is complete and that the
20 hospital has the critical elements required for a
21 state-approved trauma center.
22 2. Timeframes provided in subsections (1)-(8) shall be
23 stayed until the department determines that the application is
24 complete and that the hospital has the critical elements
25 required for a state-approved trauma center.
26 (4) Between May 1 and October 1 of each year, the
27 department and, for any hospital that operates within the
28 geographic area of a local or regional trauma agency, the
29 local or regional trauma agency shall conduct an in-depth
30 evaluation of all applications found acceptable in the
31 provisional review. The local or regional trauma agency shall
6
CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
Florida House of Representatives - 1997 HB 895
507-149-97
1 conduct an in-depth evaluation of the application and shall
2 submit comments and recommendations to the department no later
3 than the close of business on June 1 of the year in which the
4 application was submitted. In reviewing the application, the
5 department shall consider the comments and recommendations
6 submitted by the local or regional trauma agency. If the
7 department makes a finding of fact or determination regarding
8 the application which is counter to the comments or
9 recommendations submitted by the local or regional trauma
10 agency, the department must provide to the local or regional
11 trauma agency, in writing, its reasons for its findings, item
12 by item. The applications must shall be evaluated against
13 criteria enumerated in the application packages as provided to
14 the hospitals by the department.
15 (6) Based on recommendations from the review team, the
16 department shall select state-approved trauma centers by July
17 1. An applicant for designation as a state-approved trauma
18 center or a state-approved pediatric trauma referral center
19 may request an extension of its provisional status if it
20 submits a corrective action plan to the department. The
21 corrective action plan must demonstrate the ability of the
22 applicant to correct deficiencies noted during the applicant's
23 onsite review conducted by the department between the previous
24 October 1 and June 1. The department may extend the
25 provisional status of an applicant for designation as a
26 state-approved trauma center or a state-approved pediatric
27 trauma referral center through December 31 if the applicant
28 provides a corrective action plan acceptable to the
29 department. The department or a team of out-of-state experts
30 assembled by the department shall conduct an onsite visit on
31 or before November 1 to confirm that the deficiencies have
7
CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
Florida House of Representatives - 1997 HB 895
507-149-97
1 been corrected. The provisional state-approved trauma center
2 or the provisional state-approved pediatric trauma referral
3 center is responsible for all costs associated with the onsite
4 visit in a manner prescribed by rule of the department. By
5 January 1, the department must approve or deny the application
6 of any provisional applicant granted an extension. Each
7 state-approved trauma center shall be granted a 7-year
8 verification period during which time it must continue to
9 maintain trauma center verification standards and acceptable
10 patient outcomes as determined by department rule. A
11 verification, unless sooner suspended or revoked,
12 automatically expires 7 years after the date of issuance, but
13 and is renewable upon application for renewal, if the
14 applicant continues to meet prescribed verification standards
15 as prescribed by rule of the department. An application for
16 renewal must be filed with the department at least 90 days
17 before the verification period ends, on forms provided by the
18 department. The forms must be limited to requesting
19 confirmation of the applicant's desire to renew its
20 verification for another 7-year period, and the applicant's
21 certification of continued compliance with trauma center
22 verification standards for trauma center facilities, staffing,
23 equipment, and programs. After July 1, 1992, Only those
24 hospitals selected as state-approved trauma centers may
25 operate as trauma centers.
26 Section 3. Within 60 days after the effective date of
27 this act, the Department of Health shall convene a task force
28 on pediatric trauma. Task force members who are to be
29 appointed by the department must include representatives of
30 health care facilities, emergency medical services providers,
31 and health care practitioners, all of whom have special
8
CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
Florida House of Representatives - 1997 HB 895
507-149-97
1 expertise or experience in the area of pediatric trauma care;
2 representatives from local and regional trauma agencies and
3 health planning councils, and representatives from the
4 Department of Health Office of Children's Medical Services.
5 Representatives from the Agency for Health Care Administration
6 who have special expertise in health planning, hospital
7 regulation, and children's health care are to be appointed by
8 the Agency for Health Care Administration. Consistent with its
9 state planning requirements as provided in section 395.4015,
10 Florida Statutes, the department shall draft a planning
11 document for pediatric trauma care and shall submit the
12 document to the chairpersons of the health care and
13 appropriations committees of each house by December 1, 1998.
14 The planning document must address the establishment of
15 minimum pediatric trauma patient case number planning
16 guidelines and must be based on a consideration of other
17 factors relevant to the planning of pediatric trauma care,
18 including, at a minimum:
19 (1) The injury severity level for which pediatric
20 trauma care is required.
21 (2) A proposal for a minimum patient care number
22 planning guideline that is based on a consideration of
23 geographic factors, relative population density of urban and
24 rural areas, and other factors important to ensuring adequate
25 geographic access to care.
26 (3) A proposal for a minimum number or range of numbers
27 of pediatric trauma cases which should be used as a pediatric
28 trauma planning guideline. In arriving at such a number, the
29 task force should consider the number of pediatric trauma
30 cases which should be treated at a pediatric trauma referral
31 center in order to maintain skill proficiencies consistent
9
CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
Florida House of Representatives - 1997 HB 895
507-149-97
1 with high-quality outcomes; to contribute to teaching,
2 research, and education; and to ensure training of future
3 pediatric trauma physicians and other pediatric trauma
4 professional specialists.
5 (4) The acceptable range of elapsed time between the
6 occurrence of pediatric trauma injury and the provision of
7 definitive care. In arriving at the acceptable range of
8 elapsed time, the task force must consider what constitutes
9 appropriate travel time from accident locations to a pediatric
10 trauma referral center and what constitutes appropriate
11 lengths of time for interfacility transfer between
12 nonpediatric trauma facilities and pediatric trauma referral
13 centers.
14 (5) The existing level of facilities available
15 throughout the state as resources for pediatric trauma care.
16 (6) The appropriate distribution of pediatric referral
17 centers relative to adult trauma centers throughout the state.
18
19 Members of the task force, excluding state employees, shall
20 serve without compensation and without reimbursement for
21 travel expenses. The activities of the task force must be
22 accomplished within existing resources and appropriations.
23 Section 4. This act shall take effect upon becoming a
24 law.
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
10
CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
Florida House of Representatives - 1997 HB 895
507-149-97
1 *****************************************
2 SENATE SUMMARY
3 Provides legislative intent regarding trauma centers and
pediatric trauma care. Prescribes the number and types of
4 patients to be treated at pediatric trauma referral
centers. Provides for selecting state-approved trauma
5 centers and pediatric trauma referral centers. Amends
procedures for renewing verification. Requires the
6 formation of a task force on pediatric trauma. Provides
for task force membership, duties, and responsibilities.
7 Requires a report to legislative committees.
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
11