Senate Bill 0070
CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
Florida Senate - 1999 SB 70
By Senator Grant
13-105-99
1 A bill to be entitled
2 An act relating to eminent domain; amending s.
3 73.0511, F.S.; providing for a written offer of
4 settlement as part of the prelitigation notice;
5 amending s. 73.071, F.S.; providing that the
6 jury must determine full compensation in
7 eminent domain actions; providing for
8 consideration of business damages; providing
9 for the determination of compensation in
10 inverse condemnation proceedings; providing for
11 consideration of mitigation by a property
12 owner; providing for construction of the term
13 "property"; creating s. 74.0205, F.S.;
14 providing for presuit negotiations; creating s.
15 74.042, F.S.; providing for mandatory
16 nonbinding mediation prior to the order of
17 taking hearing; amending s. 337.271, F.S.;
18 providing for the simplification of the
19 acquisition negotiation process; providing an
20 effective date.
21
22 Be It Enacted by the Legislature of the State of Florida:
23
24 Section 1. Section 73.0511, Florida Statutes, is
25 amended to read:
26 73.0511 Prelitigation notice.--At least 60 days before
27 Prior to instituting litigation, the condemning authority
28 shall make a written offer of settlement to each defendant for
29 payment of full compensation under s. 73.071. The offer must
30 name the defendant to whom it is made, briefly summarize any
31 relevant conditions, identify all interested parties who might
1
CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
Florida Senate - 1999 SB 70
13-105-99
1 have an apportionable interest in the compensation, and state
2 that the offer is considered to have been rejected unless
3 accepted in writing within 30 days after receipt. At the time
4 the offer is made, the condemning authority shall identify and
5 make available to each defendant the appraisal information and
6 construction plans, if any, upon which the offer is based. The
7 condemning authority shall also notify each defendant the fee
8 owners of all statutory rights under s. 73.091.
9 Section 2. Section 73.071, Florida Statutes, is
10 amended to read:
11 73.071 Jury trial; full compensation; severance
12 damages; business damages.--
13 (1) When the action is at issue, and only upon notice
14 and hearing to set the cause for trial, the court shall
15 impanel a jury of 12 persons as soon as practical considering
16 the reasonable necessities of the court and of the parties,
17 and giving preference to the trial of eminent domain cases
18 over other civil actions, and submit the issue of full
19 compensation to them for determination, which issue shall be
20 tried in the same manner as other issues of fact are tried in
21 the circuit courts. The court shall give priority to the trial
22 of eminent domain cases over other civil actions.
23 (2) The amount of such full compensation shall be
24 determined as of the date of trial, or the date upon which
25 title passes, whichever shall occur first. The jury shall
26 determine full compensation based upon a claim of inverse
27 condemnation as of the date of appropriation.
28 (3) The jury shall determine solely the amount of full
29 compensation to be paid, which compensation shall include:
30 (a) The value of the property sought to be
31 appropriated by direct or inverse condemnation;
2
CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
Florida Senate - 1999 SB 70
13-105-99
1 (b) Where less than the entire property is sought to
2 be appropriated, any damages to remaining property the
3 remainder caused by that appropriation the taking, including,
4 any damage resulting from the project that necessitated or
5 caused that the property be appropriated; when the action is
6 by the Department of Transportation, county, municipality,
7 board, district or other public body for the condemnation of a
8 right-of-way, and the effect of the taking of the property
9 involved may damage or destroy an established business of more
10 than 5 years' standing, owned by the party whose lands are
11 being so taken, located upon adjoining lands owned or held by
12 such party, the probable damages to such business which the
13 denial of the use of the property so taken may reasonably
14 cause; any person claiming the right to recover such special
15 damages shall set forth in his or her written defenses the
16 nature and extent of such damages; and
17 (c) Any damage to an established business of 3 years'
18 standing, operated at the location from which property has
19 been appropriated by a governmental entity through direct or
20 inverse condemnation, including any damage resulting from the
21 project that necessitated or caused that the property be
22 appropriated. Such damages shall include, but are not limited
23 to, those suffered by agricultural operations, as defined in
24 s. 570.02(1), as a result of the appropriation of agricultural
25 property. Evidence of a claimant's ability to mitigate
26 business damage onsite or by relocating to another comparable
27 location in the same market trade area may be considered. Any
28 increased costs of operation and reasonable expenses of
29 mitigation resulting from the onsite mitigation plan or from
30 the relocation of the business to another comparable location
31 in the same market trade area, together with moving costs and
3
CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
Florida Senate - 1999 SB 70
13-105-99
1 downtime losses, must be included when determining business
2 damages payable to the claimant; and
3 (d)(c) Where the appropriation is of property upon
4 which a mobile home, other than a travel trailer as defined in
5 s. 320.01, is located, whether or not the owner of the mobile
6 home is an owner or lessee of the property involved, and the
7 effect of the appropriation taking of the property involved
8 requires the relocation of such mobile home, the reasonable
9 removal or relocation expenses incurred by such mobile home
10 owner, not to exceed the replacement value of such mobile
11 home. The compensation paid to a mobile home owner under this
12 paragraph shall preclude an award to a mobile home park owner
13 for such expenses of removal or relocation. Any mobile home
14 owner claiming the right to such removal or relocation
15 expenses shall set forth in his or her written defenses the
16 nature and extent of such expenses. This paragraph shall not
17 apply to any governmental authority exercising its power of
18 eminent domain when reasonable removal or relocation expenses
19 must be paid to mobile home owners under other provisions of
20 law or agency rule applicable to such exercise of power.
21
22 For the purpose of determining compensation under paragraphs
23 (a), (b), and (c), the term "property" is to be broadly
24 construed and includes, but is not limited to, land,
25 improvements, farm operations, and rights of access, air,
26 light, and view.
27 (4) When the action is by the Department of
28 Transportation, county, municipality, board, district, or
29 other public body for the condemnation of a road, canal,
30 levee, or water control facility right-of-way, The
31 enhancement, if any, in value of the remaining adjoining
4
CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
Florida Senate - 1999 SB 70
13-105-99
1 property of the defendant property owner by reason of the
2 project construction or improvement made or contemplated or
3 constructed by the petitioner shall be offset against the
4 damage, if any, resulting to such remaining adjoining property
5 of the defendant property owner by reason of the project
6 contemplated or constructed construction or improvement.
7 However, such enhancement in the value shall not be offset
8 against the value of the property appropriated, and if such
9 enhancement in value shall exceed the damage, if any, to the
10 remaining adjoining property, there shall be no recovery over
11 against such property owner for such excess.
12 (5) Any increase or decrease in the value of any
13 property to be acquired which occurs after the scope of the
14 project for which the property is being acquired is known in
15 the market, and which is solely a result of the knowledge of
16 the project location, shall not be considered in arriving at
17 the value of the property acquired. For the purpose of this
18 section, the scope of the project for which the property is
19 being acquired shall be presumed to be known in the market on
20 or after the condemnor executes a resolution which depicts the
21 location of the project.
22 (6) The jury shall view the subject property upon
23 demand by any party or by order of the court.
24 (7) If the jury cannot agree on a verdict the court
25 shall discharge them, impanel a new jury, and proceed with the
26 trial.
27 Section 3. Section 74.0205, Florida Statutes, is
28 created to read:
29 74.0205 Presuit negotiations.--The condemning
30 authority shall negotiate in good faith with the owner of a
31 parcel to be acquired and shall attempt to arrive at an
5
CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
Florida Senate - 1999 SB 70
13-105-99
1 agreed-upon amount of compensation to be paid for the parcel.
2 If a settlement is reached before litigation, the condemning
3 authority shall promptly pay a reasonable appraisal fee,
4 reasonable accountant's fee, reasonable attorney's fee, and
5 other reasonable costs. The property owner may file a
6 complaint in the circuit court in the county in which the
7 property is located to recover reasonable costs.
8 Section 4. Section 74.042, Florida Statutes, is
9 created to read:
10 74.042 Mandatory mediation.--Upon motion of any party,
11 the court shall order that the case be submitted to nonbinding
12 mediation under s. 44.102 prior to conducting the order of
13 taking hearing under s. 74.051.
14 Section 5. Section 337.271, Florida Statutes, is
15 amended to read:
16 337.271 Negotiations for acquisitions.--
17 (1) The department shall negotiate in good faith with
18 the owner of a parcel to be acquired and shall attempt to
19 arrive at an agreed amount of compensation to be paid for the
20 parcel and at the inception of the negotiations shall provide
21 the owner with the right-of-way maps and notify the owner of
22 statutory rights under s. 73.091 and s. 73.092.
23 (2) At the inception of negotiation for acquisition,
24 the department shall notify the fee owner of the following:
25 (a) That all or a portion of his or her property is
26 necessary for a transportation facility or transportation
27 corridor;
28 (b) The nature of the project for which the parcel is
29 deemed necessary, the project number, and the parcel
30 designation of the property to be acquired;
31
6
CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
Florida Senate - 1999 SB 70
13-105-99
1 (c) The district office of the department from which
2 the owner may obtain right-of-way maps reflecting the proposed
3 taking;
4 (d) The fee owner's statutory rights under ss. 73.091
5 and 73.092; and
6 (e) The fee owner's rights and responsibilities under
7 subsections (3), (4), (5), and (6).
8 (3) The notice shall be sent by certified mail, return
9 receipt requested, to the fee owner's last known address
10 listed on the county ad valorem tax roll. Notice to one owner
11 constitutes notice to all owners on multiple-ownership
12 property. The return of the notice as undeliverable by the
13 postal authorities constitutes compliance with this provision.
14 The department is not required to give notice to a person who
15 acquires title to the property subsequent to the notice
16 required by this section.
17 (4) The fee owner may, within 120 days after receipt
18 of the notice required by subsection (2) or at a later date
19 specified by the department, submit a complete appraisal
20 report relating to the parcel to be acquired. The fee owner
21 may waive his or her right to the 120 days to obtain an
22 appraisal by providing the department with written notice of
23 such waiver. If a report is submitted, it shall contain all
24 data and information upon which the appraiser's conclusions
25 are based and shall be prepared by a state-certified real
26 estate appraiser as defined in chapter 475 and who has been
27 qualified by the department. A list of those state-certified
28 real estate appraisers, as defined in chapter 475, currently
29 qualified by the department shall be attached to the letter
30 submitted to the fee owner. On multiple-ownership property,
31
7
CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
Florida Senate - 1999 SB 70
13-105-99
1 the fee owner is collectively entitled to only one appraisal
2 report.
3 (5) If the business owner intends to claim business
4 damages pursuant to s. 73.071(3)(b), he or she may, within 120
5 days after receipt of the notice required by subsection (2) or
6 at a later time specified by the department, submit to the
7 department a complete estimate of business damages to the
8 property. The fee owner may waive his or her right to the 120
9 days to obtain an estimate of business damages by providing
10 the department with written notice of such waiver. If an
11 estimate is submitted, it shall explain the nature and extent
12 of such damages and shall be prepared by either the owner or a
13 certified public accountant. If the business owner elects to
14 submit an estimate of business damages to the department, he
15 or she shall also permit the department to copy and examine,
16 at the owner's convenience, such of the owner's business
17 records as the department determines to be necessary for it to
18 arrive at an estimate of business damages.
19 (6) Upon submission of an invoice which complies with
20 the requirements of this subsection, the department shall pay
21 all reasonable costs, including reasonable attorney's fees,
22 incurred on behalf of a property owner who proceeds to
23 prelitigation negotiation settlement pursuant to the
24 provisions of this section. The attorney's fees shall be based
25 upon the criteria of s. 73.092. The invoice shall include
26 complete time records and a detailed statement of services
27 performed and time spent performing such services. Reasonable
28 appraisal or accountant fees as authorized by this section
29 shall not exceed the general or customary hourly rate for
30 appraisal or accounting fees in the community. If the parties
31 cannot agree on the amount of costs and attorney's fees to be
8
CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
Florida Senate - 1999 SB 70
13-105-99
1 paid by the department, the property owner may file a
2 complaint in the circuit court in the county where the
3 property is located to recover reasonable attorney's fees and
4 costs.
5 (7) Within 30 days after receipt of the fee owner's
6 appraisal report and the estimate of business damages if
7 submitted, the department shall submit to the owner all
8 appraisal reports prepared for the department which relate to
9 the owner's parcel and any estimate of business damages
10 prepared.
11 (8) After receipt of the appraisal report prepared for
12 the fee owner and the estimate of business damages if
13 submitted, the department shall make a written offer of
14 purchase to the fee owner and business owner, if any, which
15 includes the value of the land and improvements taken and any
16 business or severance damages.
17 (9) After exchanging appraisal reports and business
18 damage reports, the parties may jointly agree to submit the
19 compensation and business damage claims to nonbinding
20 mediation. The mediation may be held after the eminent domain
21 action is filed, if the department must file the action to
22 meet construction schedules. The parties shall agree upon a
23 mediator certified pursuant to s. 44.102.
24 (10) If the department agrees to mediation, the fee
25 owner or business owner may submit to the department an
26 invoice, which complies with this section, for payment for the
27 appraisal reports, business damage reports, and other
28 reasonable costs. Upon receipt of such invoice, the
29 department shall promptly pay a reasonable appraisal fee,
30 reasonable accountant's fee, and other reasonable costs. If
31 the parties cannot agree on the amount of costs to be paid by
9
CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
Florida Senate - 1999 SB 70
13-105-99
1 the department, the property owner may file a complaint in the
2 circuit court in the county in which the property is located
3 to recover reasonable costs.
4 (2)(11) Evidence of negotiations, or evidence of any
5 written or oral statements used in mediation, conducted by the
6 parties pursuant to this section is not admissible in any
7 subsequent proceeding.
8 Section 6. This act shall take effect July 1, 1999.
9
10 *****************************************
11 SENATE SUMMARY
12 In eminent domain proceedings provides for: a simplified
acquisition negotiation process; mandatory mediation
13 prior to hearing on the order of taking; the jury to
award full compensation both for direct and inverse
14 condemnation appropriations of property; and
consideration of mitigation, and of the expenses of
15 mitigation, by a business owner. Decreases from 5 years
to 3 years the length of time a business must have been
16 established before business damages are considered.
Directs that the term "property" be broadly construed in
17 determining compensation.
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
10