1 | The Health Care Regulation Committee recommends the following: |
2 |
|
3 | Council/Committee Substitute |
4 | Remove the entire bill and insert: |
5 | A bill to be entitled |
6 | An act relating to medical malpractice insurance; creating |
7 | the Enterprise Act for Patient Protection and Provider |
8 | Liability; providing legislative findings; amending s. |
9 | 395.0197, F.S., relating to internal risk management |
10 | programs; conforming provisions to changes made by the |
11 | act; amending s. 458.320, F.S.; exempting certain |
12 | physicians who perform surgery in certain patient safety |
13 | facilities from the requirement to establish financial |
14 | responsibility; requiring a licensed physician who is |
15 | covered for medical negligence claims by a hospital that |
16 | assumes liability under the act to prominently post notice |
17 | or provide a written statement to patients; requiring a |
18 | licensed physician who meets certain requirements for |
19 | payment or settlement of a medical malpractice claim and |
20 | who is covered for medical negligence claims by a hospital |
21 | that assumes liability under the act to prominently post |
22 | notice or provide a written statement to patients; |
23 | amending s. 459.0085, F.S.; exempting certain osteopathic |
24 | physicians who perform surgery in certain patient safety |
25 | facilities from the requirement to establish financial |
26 | responsibility; requiring a licensed osteopathic physician |
27 | who is covered for medical negligence claims by a hospital |
28 | that assumes liability under the act to prominently post |
29 | notice or provide a written statement to patients; |
30 | requiring a licensee of osteopathic medicine who meets |
31 | certain requirements for payment or settlement of a |
32 | medical malpractice claim and who is covered for medical |
33 | negligence claims by a hospital that assumes liability |
34 | under the act to prominently post notice or provide a |
35 | written statement to patients; creating s. 627.41485, |
36 | F.S.; authorizing insurers to offer liability insurance |
37 | coverage to physicians which has an exclusion for certain |
38 | acts of medical negligence under certain conditions; |
39 | authorizing the Department of Financial Services to adopt |
40 | rules; amending s. 766.316, F.S.; requiring hospitals that |
41 | assume liability for affected physicians under the act to |
42 | provide notice to obstetrical patients regarding the |
43 | limited no-fault alternative to birth-related neurological |
44 | injuries; amending s. 766.110, F.S.; requiring hospitals |
45 | that assume liability for acts of medical negligence under |
46 | the act to carry insurance; requiring the hospital's |
47 | policy regarding medical liability insurance to satisfy |
48 | certain statutory financial responsibility requirements; |
49 | authorizing an insurer who is authorized to write casualty |
50 | insurance to write such coverage; authorizing certain |
51 | hospitals to indemnify certain medical staff for legal |
52 | liability of loss, damages, or expenses arising from |
53 | medical negligence within hospital premises; requiring a |
54 | hospital to acquire a policy of professional liability |
55 | insurance or a fund for malpractice coverage; requiring an |
56 | annual certified financial statement to the Agency for |
57 | Health Care Administration; authorizing certain hospitals |
58 | to charge physicians a fee for malpractice coverage; |
59 | preserving a hospital's ability to indemnify certain |
60 | medical staff members; creating s. 766.401, F.S.; |
61 | providing definitions; creating s. 766.402, F.S.; |
62 | authorizing an eligible hospital to petition the Agency |
63 | for Health Care Administration to enter an order |
64 | certifying the hospital as a patient safety facility; |
65 | providing requirements for certification as a patient |
66 | safety facility; creating s. 766.403, F.S.; providing |
67 | requirements for a hospital to demonstrate that it is |
68 | engaged in a common enterprise for the care and treatment |
69 | of patients; specifying required patient safety measures; |
70 | prohibiting a report or document generated under the act |
71 | from being admissible or discoverable as evidence; |
72 | creating s. 766.404, F.S.; authorizing the agency to enter |
73 | an order certifying a hospital as a patient safety |
74 | facility and providing that the hospital bears liability |
75 | for acts of medical negligence for its health care |
76 | providers or an agent of the hospital; providing that |
77 | certain persons or entities are not liable for medically |
78 | negligent acts occurring in a certified patient safety |
79 | facility; requiring that an affected practitioner |
80 | prominently post notice regarding exemption from personal |
81 | liability; requiring an affected physician who is covered |
82 | by an enterprise plan in a licensed facility that receives |
83 | sovereign immunity to prominently post notice regarding |
84 | exemption from personal liability; providing that an |
85 | agency order certifying approval of an enterprise plan is |
86 | evidence of a hospital's compliance with applicable |
87 | patient safety requirements; providing circumstances in |
88 | which notice is not required; providing that the order |
89 | certifying approval of an enterprise plan applies |
90 | prospectively to causes of action for medical negligence; |
91 | authorizing the agency to conduct onsite examinations of a |
92 | licensed facility; providing circumstances under which the |
93 | agency may revoke its order certifying approval of an |
94 | enterprise plan; providing that an employee or agent of a |
95 | certified patient safety facility may not be joined as a |
96 | defendant in an action for medical negligence; requiring |
97 | an affected practitioner to cooperate in good faith in an |
98 | investigation of a claim for medical malpractice; |
99 | providing a cause of action for failure of a physician to |
100 | act in good faith; providing that strict liability or |
101 | liability without fault is not imposed for medical |
102 | incidents that occur in the affected facility; providing |
103 | requirements that a claimant must prove to demonstrate |
104 | medical negligence by an employee, agent, or medical staff |
105 | of a licensed facility; providing that the act does not |
106 | create an independent cause of action or waive sovereign |
107 | immunity; creating s. 766.405, F.S.; requiring an eligible |
108 | hospital to execute an enterprise plan; requiring certain |
109 | conditions to be contained within an enterprise plan; |
110 | creating s. 766.406, F.S.; requiring a certified patient |
111 | safety facility to report medical incidents occurring on |
112 | its premises and adverse findings of medical negligence to |
113 | the Department of Health; requiring certified patient |
114 | safety facilities to perform certain peer review |
115 | functions; creating s. 766.407, F.S.; providing that an |
116 | enterprise plan may provide clinical privileges to certain |
117 | persons; requiring certain organizations to share in the |
118 | cost of omnibus medical liability insurance premiums |
119 | subject to certain conditions; authorizing a licensed |
120 | facility to impose a reasonable assessment against an |
121 | affected practitioner who commits medical negligence; |
122 | providing for the revocation of clinical privileges for |
123 | failure to pay the assessment; exempting certain employees |
124 | and agents from such assessments; creating s. 766.408, |
125 | F.S.; requiring a certified patient safety facility to |
126 | submit an annual report to the agency and the Legislature; |
127 | providing requirements for the annual report; providing |
128 | that the annual report may include certain information |
129 | from the Office of Insurance Regulation within the |
130 | Department of Financial Services; providing that the |
131 | annual report is subject to public records requirements, |
132 | but is not admissible as evidence in a legal proceeding; |
133 | creating s. 766.409, F.S.; authorizing certain teaching |
134 | hospitals and eligible hospitals to petition the agency |
135 | for certification; providing for limitations on damages |
136 | for eligible hospitals that are certified for compliance |
137 | with certain patient safety measures; authorizing the |
138 | agency to conduct onsite examinations of certified |
139 | eligible hospitals; authorizing the agency to revoke its |
140 | order certifying approval of an enterprise plan; providing |
141 | that an agency order certifying approval of an enterprise |
142 | plan is evidence of a hospital's compliance with |
143 | applicable patient safety requirements; providing that |
144 | evidence of noncompliance is inadmissible in any action |
145 | for medical malpractice; providing that entry of the |
146 | agency's order does not impose enterprise liability on the |
147 | licensed facility for acts or omissions of medical |
148 | negligence; providing that a hospital may not be approved |
149 | for certification for both enterprise liability and |
150 | limitations on damages; creating s. 766.410, F.S.; |
151 | providing rulemaking authority; amending s. 768.28, F.S.; |
152 | providing limitations on payment of a claim or judgment |
153 | for an action for medical negligence within a certified |
154 | patient safety facility that is covered by sovereign |
155 | immunity; providing definitions; providing that a |
156 | certified patient safety facility is an agent of a state |
157 | university board of trustees to the extent that the |
158 | licensed facility is solely liable for acts of medical |
159 | negligence of physicians providing health care services |
160 | within the licensed facility; specifying that certain |
161 | certified patient safety facilities are agents of a state |
162 | university board of trustees under certain circumstances; |
163 | authorizing licensed facilities to secure limits of |
164 | liability protection from certain self-insurance programs; |
165 | providing requirements for commencing an action for |
166 | certain medical negligence; providing procedures; |
167 | providing limitations; providing for severability; |
168 | providing for broad statutory view of the act; providing |
169 | for self-execution of the act; providing an effective |
170 | date. |
171 |
|
172 | Be It Enacted by the Legislature of the State of Florida: |
173 |
|
174 | Section 1. Popular name.--This act may be cited as the |
175 | "Enterprise Act for Patient Protection and Provider Liability." |
176 | Section 2. Legislative findings.-- |
177 | (1) The Legislature finds that this state is in the midst |
178 | of a prolonged medical malpractice insurance crisis that has |
179 | serious adverse effects on patients, practitioners, licensed |
180 | healthcare facilities, and all residents of this state. |
181 | (2) The Legislature finds that hospitals are central |
182 | components of the modern health care delivery system. |
183 | (3) The Legislature finds that many of the most serious |
184 | incidents of medical negligence occur in hospitals, where the |
185 | most seriously ill patients are treated, and where surgical |
186 | procedures are performed. |
187 | (4) The Legislature finds that modern hospitals are |
188 | complex organizations, that medical care and treatment in |
189 | hospitals is a complex process, and that, increasingly, medical |
190 | care and treatment in hospitals is a common enterprise involving |
191 | an array of responsible employees, agents, and other persons, |
192 | such as physicians, who are authorized to exercise clinical |
193 | privileges within the premises. |
194 | (5) The Legislature finds that an increasing number of |
195 | medical incidents in hospitals involve a combination of acts and |
196 | omissions by employees, agents, and other persons, such as |
197 | physicians, who are authorized to exercise clinical privileges |
198 | within the premises. |
199 | (6) The Legislature finds that the medical malpractice |
200 | insurance crisis in this state can be alleviated by the adoption |
201 | of innovative approaches for patient protection in hospitals |
202 | which can lead to a reduction in medical errors. |
203 | (7) The Legislature finds statutory incentives are |
204 | necessary to facilitate innovative approaches for patient |
205 | protection in hospitals. |
206 | (8) The Legislature finds that an enterprise approach to |
207 | patient protection and provider liability in hospitals will lead |
208 | to a reduction in the frequency and severity of incidents of |
209 | medical malpractice in hospitals. |
210 | (9) The Legislature finds that a reduction in the |
211 | frequency and severity of incidents of medical malpractice in |
212 | hospitals will reduce attorney's fees and other expenses |
213 | inherent in the medical liability system. |
214 | (10) The Legislature finds that making high-quality health |
215 | care available to the residents of this state is an overwhelming |
216 | public necessity. |
217 | (11) The Legislature finds that medical education in this |
218 | state is an overwhelming public necessity. |
219 | (12) The Legislature finds that statutory teaching |
220 | hospitals and hospitals owned by and operated by universities |
221 | that maintain accredited medical schools are essential for high- |
222 | quality medical care and medical education in this state. |
223 | (13) The Legislature finds that the critical mission of |
224 | statutory teaching hospitals and hospitals owned and operated by |
225 | universities that maintain accredited medical schools is |
226 | severely undermined by the ongoing medical malpractice crisis. |
227 | (14) The Legislature finds that statutory teaching |
228 | hospitals and hospitals owned and operated by universities that |
229 | maintain accredited medical schools are appropriate health care |
230 | facilities for the implementation of innovative approaches to |
231 | patient protection and provider liability. |
232 | (15) The Legislature finds an overwhelming public |
233 | necessity to impose reasonable limitations on actions for |
234 | medical malpractice against statutory teaching hospitals and |
235 | hospitals that are owned and operated by universities that |
236 | maintain accredited medical schools, in furtherance of the |
237 | critical public interest in promoting access to high-quality |
238 | medical care, medical education, and innovative approaches to |
239 | patient protection. |
240 | (16) The Legislature finds an overwhelming public |
241 | necessity for statutory teaching hospitals and hospitals owned |
242 | and operated by universities that maintain accredited medical |
243 | schools to implement innovative measures for patient protection |
244 | and provider liability in order to generate empirical data for |
245 | state policymakers on the effectiveness of these measures. Such |
246 | data may lead to broader application of these measures in a |
247 | wider array of hospitals after a reasonable period of evaluation |
248 | and review. |
249 | (17) The Legislature finds an overwhelming public |
250 | necessity to promote the academic mission of statutory teaching |
251 | hospitals and hospitals owned and operated by universities that |
252 | maintain accredited medical schools. Furthermore, the |
253 | Legislature finds that the academic mission of these medical |
254 | facilities is materially enhanced by statutory authority for the |
255 | implementation of innovative approaches to patient protection |
256 | and provider liability. Such approaches can be carefully studied |
257 | and learned by medical students, medical school faculty, and |
258 | affiliated physicians in appropriate clinical settings, thereby |
259 | enlarging the body of knowledge concerning patient protection |
260 | and provider liability which is essential for advancement of |
261 | patient safety, reduction of expenses inherent in the medical |
262 | liability system, and curtailment of the medical malpractice |
263 | insurance crisis in this state. |
264 | Section 3. Subsection (3) of section 395.0197, Florida |
265 | Statutes, is amended to read: |
266 | 395.0197 Internal risk management program.-- |
267 | (3) In addition to the programs mandated by this section, |
268 | other innovative approaches intended to reduce the frequency and |
269 | severity of medical malpractice and patient injury claims shall |
270 | be encouraged and their implementation and operation |
271 | facilitated. Such additional approaches may include extending |
272 | internal risk management programs to health care providers' |
273 | offices and the assuming of provider liability by a licensed |
274 | health care facility for acts or omissions occurring within the |
275 | licensed facility pursuant to the Enterprise Act for Patient |
276 | Protection and Provider Liability, inclusive of ss. 766.401- |
277 | 766.409. Each licensed facility shall annually report to the |
278 | agency and the Department of Health the name and judgments |
279 | entered against each health care practitioner for which it |
280 | assumes liability. The agency and Department of Health, in their |
281 | respective annual reports, shall include statistics that report |
282 | the number of licensed facilities that assume such liability and |
283 | the number of health care practitioners, by profession, for whom |
284 | they assume liability. |
285 | Section 4. Subsection (2) and paragraphs (f) and (g) of |
286 | subsection (5) of section 458.320, Florida Statutes, are amended |
287 | to read: |
288 | 458.320 Financial responsibility.-- |
289 | (2) Physicians who perform surgery in an ambulatory |
290 | surgical center licensed under chapter 395 and, as a continuing |
291 | condition of hospital staff privileges, physicians who have |
292 | staff privileges must also establish financial responsibility by |
293 | one of the following methods: |
294 | (a) Establishing and maintaining an escrow account |
295 | consisting of cash or assets eligible for deposit in accordance |
296 | with s. 625.52 in the per claim amounts specified in paragraph |
297 | (b). The required escrow amount set forth in this paragraph may |
298 | not be used for litigation costs or attorney's fees for the |
299 | defense of any medical malpractice claim. |
300 | (b) Obtaining and maintaining professional liability |
301 | coverage in an amount not less than $250,000 per claim, with a |
302 | minimum annual aggregate of not less than $750,000 from an |
303 | authorized insurer as defined under s. 624.09, from a surplus |
304 | lines insurer as defined under s. 626.914(2), from a risk |
305 | retention group as defined under s. 627.942, from the Joint |
306 | Underwriting Association established under s. 627.351(4), |
307 | through a plan of self-insurance as provided in s. 627.357, or |
308 | through a plan of self-insurance which meets the conditions |
309 | specified for satisfying financial responsibility in s. 766.110. |
310 | The required coverage amount set forth in this paragraph may not |
311 | be used for litigation costs or attorney's fees for the defense |
312 | of any medical malpractice claim. |
313 | (c) Obtaining and maintaining an unexpired irrevocable |
314 | letter of credit, established pursuant to chapter 675, in an |
315 | amount not less than $250,000 per claim, with a minimum |
316 | aggregate availability of credit of not less than $750,000. The |
317 | letter of credit must be payable to the physician as beneficiary |
318 | upon presentment of a final judgment indicating liability and |
319 | awarding damages to be paid by the physician or upon presentment |
320 | of a settlement agreement signed by all parties to such |
321 | agreement when such final judgment or settlement is a result of |
322 | a claim arising out of the rendering of, or the failure to |
323 | render, medical care and services. The letter of credit may not |
324 | be used for litigation costs or attorney's fees for the defense |
325 | of any medical malpractice claim. The letter of credit must be |
326 | nonassignable and nontransferable. The letter of credit must be |
327 | issued by any bank or savings association organized and existing |
328 | under the laws of this state or any bank or savings association |
329 | organized under the laws of the United States which has its |
330 | principal place of business in this state or has a branch office |
331 | that is authorized under the laws of this state or of the United |
332 | States to receive deposits in this state. |
333 |
|
334 | This subsection shall be inclusive of the coverage in subsection |
335 | (1). A physician who only performs surgery or who has only |
336 | clinical privileges or admitting privileges in one or more |
337 | certified patient safety facilities, which health care facility |
338 | or facilities are legally liable for medical negligence of |
339 | affected practitioners, pursuant to the Enterprise Act for |
340 | Patient Protection and Provider Liability, inclusive of ss. |
341 | 766.401-766.409, is exempt from the requirements of this |
342 | subsection. |
343 | (5) The requirements of subsections (1), (2), and (3) do |
344 | not apply to: |
345 | (f) Any person holding an active license under this |
346 | chapter who meets all of the following criteria: |
347 | 1. The licensee has held an active license to practice in |
348 | this state or another state or some combination thereof for more |
349 | than 15 years. |
350 | 2. The licensee has either retired from the practice of |
351 | medicine or maintains a part-time practice of no more than 1,000 |
352 | patient contact hours per year. |
353 | 3. The licensee has had no more than two claims for |
354 | medical malpractice resulting in an indemnity exceeding $25,000 |
355 | within the previous 5-year period. |
356 | 4. The licensee has not been convicted of, or pled guilty |
357 | or nolo contendere to, any criminal violation specified in this |
358 | chapter or the medical practice act of any other state. |
359 | 5. The licensee has not been subject within the last 10 |
360 | years of practice to license revocation or suspension for any |
361 | period of time; probation for a period of 3 years or longer; or |
362 | a fine of $500 or more for a violation of this chapter or the |
363 | medical practice act of another jurisdiction. The regulatory |
364 | agency's acceptance of a physician's relinquishment of a |
365 | license, stipulation, consent order, or other settlement, |
366 | offered in response to or in anticipation of the filing of |
367 | administrative charges against the physician's license, |
368 | constitutes action against the physician's license for the |
369 | purposes of this paragraph. |
370 | 6. The licensee has submitted a form supplying necessary |
371 | information as required by the department and an affidavit |
372 | affirming compliance with this paragraph. |
373 | 7. The licensee must submit biennially to the department |
374 | certification stating compliance with the provisions of this |
375 | paragraph. The licensee must, upon request, demonstrate to the |
376 | department information verifying compliance with this paragraph. |
377 |
|
378 | A licensee who meets the requirements of this paragraph must |
379 | post notice in the form of a sign prominently displayed in the |
380 | reception area and clearly noticeable by all patients or provide |
381 | a written statement to any person to whom medical services are |
382 | being provided. The sign or statement must read as follows: |
383 | "Under Florida law, physicians are generally required to carry |
384 | medical malpractice insurance or otherwise demonstrate financial |
385 | responsibility to cover potential claims for medical |
386 | malpractice. However, certain part-time physicians who meet |
387 | state requirements are exempt from the financial responsibility |
388 | law. YOUR DOCTOR MEETS THESE REQUIREMENTS AND HAS DECIDED NOT TO |
389 | CARRY MEDICAL MALPRACTICE INSURANCE. This notice is provided |
390 | pursuant to Florida law." In addition, a licensee who is covered |
391 | for claims of medical negligence arising from care and treatment |
392 | of patients in a hospital that assumes sole and exclusive |
393 | liability for all such claims pursuant to the Enterprise Act for |
394 | Patient Protection and Provider Liability, inclusive of ss. |
395 | 766.401-766.409, shall post notice in the form of a sign |
396 | prominently displayed in the reception area and clearly |
397 | noticeable by all patients or provide a written statement to any |
398 | person for whom the physician may provide medical care and |
399 | treatment in any such hospital in accordance with the |
400 | requirements of s. 766.404. |
401 | (g) Any person holding an active license under this |
402 | chapter who agrees to meet all of the following criteria: |
403 | 1. Upon the entry of an adverse final judgment arising |
404 | from a medical malpractice arbitration award, from a claim of |
405 | medical malpractice either in contract or tort, or from |
406 | noncompliance with the terms of a settlement agreement arising |
407 | from a claim of medical malpractice either in contract or tort, |
408 | the licensee shall pay the judgment creditor the lesser of the |
409 | entire amount of the judgment with all accrued interest or |
410 | either $100,000, if the physician is licensed pursuant to this |
411 | chapter but does not maintain hospital staff privileges, or |
412 | $250,000, if the physician is licensed pursuant to this chapter |
413 | and maintains hospital staff privileges, within 60 days after |
414 | the date such judgment became final and subject to execution, |
415 | unless otherwise mutually agreed to in writing by the parties. |
416 | Such adverse final judgment shall include any cross-claim, |
417 | counterclaim, or claim for indemnity or contribution arising |
418 | from the claim of medical malpractice. Upon notification of the |
419 | existence of an unsatisfied judgment or payment pursuant to this |
420 | subparagraph, the department shall notify the licensee by |
421 | certified mail that he or she shall be subject to disciplinary |
422 | action unless, within 30 days from the date of mailing, he or |
423 | she either: |
424 | a. Shows proof that the unsatisfied judgment has been paid |
425 | in the amount specified in this subparagraph; or |
426 | b. Furnishes the department with a copy of a timely filed |
427 | notice of appeal and either: |
428 | (I) A copy of a supersedeas bond properly posted in the |
429 | amount required by law; or |
430 | (II) An order from a court of competent jurisdiction |
431 | staying execution on the final judgment pending disposition of |
432 | the appeal. |
433 | 2. The Department of Health shall issue an emergency order |
434 | suspending the license of any licensee who, after 30 days |
435 | following receipt of a notice from the Department of Health, has |
436 | failed to: satisfy a medical malpractice claim against him or |
437 | her; furnish the Department of Health a copy of a timely filed |
438 | notice of appeal; furnish the Department of Health a copy of a |
439 | supersedeas bond properly posted in the amount required by law; |
440 | or furnish the Department of Health an order from a court of |
441 | competent jurisdiction staying execution on the final judgment |
442 | pending disposition of the appeal. |
443 | 3. Upon the next meeting of the probable cause panel of |
444 | the board following 30 days after the date of mailing the notice |
445 | of disciplinary action to the licensee, the panel shall make a |
446 | determination of whether probable cause exists to take |
447 | disciplinary action against the licensee pursuant to |
448 | subparagraph 1. |
449 | 4. If the board determines that the factual requirements |
450 | of subparagraph 1. are met, it shall take disciplinary action as |
451 | it deems appropriate against the licensee. Such disciplinary |
452 | action shall include, at a minimum, probation of the license |
453 | with the restriction that the licensee must make payments to the |
454 | judgment creditor on a schedule determined by the board to be |
455 | reasonable and within the financial capability of the physician. |
456 | Notwithstanding any other disciplinary penalty imposed, the |
457 | disciplinary penalty may include suspension of the license for a |
458 | period not to exceed 5 years. In the event that an agreement to |
459 | satisfy a judgment has been met, the board shall remove any |
460 | restriction on the license. |
461 | 5. The licensee has completed a form supplying necessary |
462 | information as required by the department. |
463 |
|
464 | A licensee who meets the requirements of this paragraph shall be |
465 | required either to post notice in the form of a sign prominently |
466 | displayed in the reception area and clearly noticeable by all |
467 | patients or to provide a written statement to any person to whom |
468 | medical services are being provided. Such sign or statement |
469 | shall state: "Under Florida law, physicians are generally |
470 | required to carry medical malpractice insurance or otherwise |
471 | demonstrate financial responsibility to cover potential claims |
472 | for medical malpractice. YOUR DOCTOR HAS DECIDED NOT TO CARRY |
473 | MEDICAL MALPRACTICE INSURANCE. This is permitted under Florida |
474 | law subject to certain conditions. Florida law imposes penalties |
475 | against noninsured physicians who fail to satisfy adverse |
476 | judgments arising from claims of medical malpractice. This |
477 | notice is provided pursuant to Florida law." In addition, a |
478 | licensee who meets the requirements of this paragraph and who is |
479 | covered for claims of medical negligence arising from care and |
480 | treatment of patients in a hospital that assumes sole and |
481 | exclusive liability for all such claims pursuant to the |
482 | Enterprise Act for Patient Protection and Provider Liability, |
483 | inclusive of ss. 766.401-766.409, shall post notice in the form |
484 | of a sign prominently displayed in the reception area and |
485 | clearly noticeable by all patients or provide a written |
486 | statement to any person for whom the physician may provide |
487 | medical care and treatment in any such hospital. The sign or |
488 | statement must adhere to the requirements of s. 766.404. |
489 | Section 5. Subsection (2) and paragraphs (f) and (g) of |
490 | subsection (5) of section 459.0085, Florida Statutes, are |
491 | amended to read: |
492 | 459.0085 Financial responsibility.-- |
493 | (2) Osteopathic physicians who perform surgery in an |
494 | ambulatory surgical center licensed under chapter 395 and, as a |
495 | continuing condition of hospital staff privileges, osteopathic |
496 | physicians who have staff privileges must also establish |
497 | financial responsibility by one of the following methods: |
498 | (a) Establishing and maintaining an escrow account |
499 | consisting of cash or assets eligible for deposit in accordance |
500 | with s. 625.52 in the per-claim amounts specified in paragraph |
501 | (b). The required escrow amount set forth in this paragraph may |
502 | not be used for litigation costs or attorney's fees for the |
503 | defense of any medical malpractice claim. |
504 | (b) Obtaining and maintaining professional liability |
505 | coverage in an amount not less than $250,000 per claim, with a |
506 | minimum annual aggregate of not less than $750,000 from an |
507 | authorized insurer as defined under s. 624.09, from a surplus |
508 | lines insurer as defined under s. 626.914(2), from a risk |
509 | retention group as defined under s. 627.942, from the Joint |
510 | Underwriting Association established under s. 627.351(4), |
511 | through a plan of self-insurance as provided in s. 627.357, or |
512 | through a plan of self-insurance that meets the conditions |
513 | specified for satisfying financial responsibility in s. 766.110. |
514 | The required coverage amount set forth in this paragraph may not |
515 | be used for litigation costs or attorney's fees for the defense |
516 | of any medical malpractice claim. |
517 | (c) Obtaining and maintaining an unexpired, irrevocable |
518 | letter of credit, established pursuant to chapter 675, in an |
519 | amount not less than $250,000 per claim, with a minimum |
520 | aggregate availability of credit of not less than $750,000. The |
521 | letter of credit must be payable to the osteopathic physician as |
522 | beneficiary upon presentment of a final judgment indicating |
523 | liability and awarding damages to be paid by the osteopathic |
524 | physician or upon presentment of a settlement agreement signed |
525 | by all parties to such agreement when such final judgment or |
526 | settlement is a result of a claim arising out of the rendering |
527 | of, or the failure to render, medical care and services. The |
528 | letter of credit may not be used for litigation costs or |
529 | attorney's fees for the defense of any medical malpractice |
530 | claim. The letter of credit must be nonassignable and |
531 | nontransferable. The letter of credit must be issued by any bank |
532 | or savings association organized and existing under the laws of |
533 | this state or any bank or savings association organized under |
534 | the laws of the United States which has its principal place of |
535 | business in this state or has a branch office that is authorized |
536 | under the laws of this state or of the United States to receive |
537 | deposits in this state. |
538 |
|
539 | This subsection shall be inclusive of the coverage in subsection |
540 | (1). An osteopathic physician who only performs surgery or who |
541 | has only clinical privileges or admitting privileges in one or |
542 | more certified patient safety facilities, which health care |
543 | facility or facilities are legally liable for medical negligence |
544 | of affected practitioners, pursuant to the Enterprise Act for |
545 | Patient Protection and Provider Liability, inclusive of ss. |
546 | 766.401-766.409, is exempt from the requirements of this |
547 | subsection. |
548 | (5) The requirements of subsections (1), (2), and (3) do |
549 | not apply to: |
550 | (f) Any person holding an active license under this |
551 | chapter who meets all of the following criteria: |
552 | 1. The licensee has held an active license to practice in |
553 | this state or another state or some combination thereof for more |
554 | than 15 years. |
555 | 2. The licensee has either retired from the practice of |
556 | osteopathic medicine or maintains a part-time practice of |
557 | osteopathic medicine of no more than 1,000 patient contact hours |
558 | per year. |
559 | 3. The licensee has had no more than two claims for |
560 | medical malpractice resulting in an indemnity exceeding $25,000 |
561 | within the previous 5-year period. |
562 | 4. The licensee has not been convicted of, or pled guilty |
563 | or nolo contendere to, any criminal violation specified in this |
564 | chapter or the practice act of any other state. |
565 | 5. The licensee has not been subject within the last 10 |
566 | years of practice to license revocation or suspension for any |
567 | period of time, probation for a period of 3 years or longer, or |
568 | a fine of $500 or more for a violation of this chapter or the |
569 | medical practice act of another jurisdiction. The regulatory |
570 | agency's acceptance of an osteopathic physician's relinquishment |
571 | of a license, stipulation, consent order, or other settlement, |
572 | offered in response to or in anticipation of the filing of |
573 | administrative charges against the osteopathic physician's |
574 | license, constitutes action against the physician's license for |
575 | the purposes of this paragraph. |
576 | 6. The licensee has submitted a form supplying necessary |
577 | information as required by the department and an affidavit |
578 | affirming compliance with this paragraph. |
579 | 7. The licensee must submit biennially to the department a |
580 | certification stating compliance with this paragraph. The |
581 | licensee must, upon request, demonstrate to the department |
582 | information verifying compliance with this paragraph. |
583 |
|
584 | A licensee who meets the requirements of this paragraph must |
585 | post notice in the form of a sign prominently displayed in the |
586 | reception area and clearly noticeable by all patients or provide |
587 | a written statement to any person to whom medical services are |
588 | being provided. The sign or statement must read as follows: |
589 | "Under Florida law, osteopathic physicians are generally |
590 | required to carry medical malpractice insurance or otherwise |
591 | demonstrate financial responsibility to cover potential claims |
592 | for medical malpractice. However, certain part-time osteopathic |
593 | physicians who meet state requirements are exempt from the |
594 | financial responsibility law. YOUR OSTEOPATHIC PHYSICIAN MEETS |
595 | THESE REQUIREMENTS AND HAS DECIDED NOT TO CARRY MEDICAL |
596 | MALPRACTICE INSURANCE. This notice is provided pursuant to |
597 | Florida law." In addition, a licensee who is covered for claims |
598 | of medical negligence arising from care and treatment of |
599 | patients in a hospital that assumes sole and exclusive liability |
600 | for all such claims pursuant to the Enterprise Act for Patient |
601 | Protection and Provider Liability, inclusive of ss. 766.401- |
602 | 766.409, shall post notice in the form of a sign prominently |
603 | displayed in the reception area and clearly noticeable by all |
604 | patients or provide a written statement to any person for whom |
605 | the osteopathic physician may provide medical care and treatment |
606 | in any such hospital in accordance with the requirements of s. |
607 | 766.404. |
608 | (g) Any person holding an active license under this |
609 | chapter who agrees to meet all of the following criteria. |
610 | 1. Upon the entry of an adverse final judgment arising |
611 | from a medical malpractice arbitration award, from a claim of |
612 | medical malpractice either in contract or tort, or from |
613 | noncompliance with the terms of a settlement agreement arising |
614 | from a claim of medical malpractice either in contract or tort, |
615 | the licensee shall pay the judgment creditor the lesser of the |
616 | entire amount of the judgment with all accrued interest or |
617 | either $100,000, if the osteopathic physician is licensed |
618 | pursuant to this chapter but does not maintain hospital staff |
619 | privileges, or $250,000, if the osteopathic physician is |
620 | licensed pursuant to this chapter and maintains hospital staff |
621 | privileges, within 60 days after the date such judgment became |
622 | final and subject to execution, unless otherwise mutually agreed |
623 | to in writing by the parties. Such adverse final judgment shall |
624 | include any cross-claim, counterclaim, or claim for indemnity or |
625 | contribution arising from the claim of medical malpractice. Upon |
626 | notification of the existence of an unsatisfied judgment or |
627 | payment pursuant to this subparagraph, the department shall |
628 | notify the licensee by certified mail that he or she shall be |
629 | subject to disciplinary action unless, within 30 days from the |
630 | date of mailing, the licensee either: |
631 | a. Shows proof that the unsatisfied judgment has been paid |
632 | in the amount specified in this subparagraph; or |
633 | b. Furnishes the department with a copy of a timely filed |
634 | notice of appeal and either: |
635 | (I) A copy of a supersedeas bond properly posted in the |
636 | amount required by law; or |
637 | (II) An order from a court of competent jurisdiction |
638 | staying execution on the final judgment, pending disposition of |
639 | the appeal. |
640 | 2. The Department of Health shall issue an emergency order |
641 | suspending the license of any licensee who, after 30 days |
642 | following receipt of a notice from the Department of Health, has |
643 | failed to: satisfy a medical malpractice claim against him or |
644 | her; furnish the Department of Health a copy of a timely filed |
645 | notice of appeal; furnish the Department of Health a copy of a |
646 | supersedeas bond properly posted in the amount required by law; |
647 | or furnish the Department of Health an order from a court of |
648 | competent jurisdiction staying execution on the final judgment |
649 | pending disposition of the appeal. |
650 | 3. Upon the next meeting of the probable cause panel of |
651 | the board following 30 days after the date of mailing the notice |
652 | of disciplinary action to the licensee, the panel shall make a |
653 | determination of whether probable cause exists to take |
654 | disciplinary action against the licensee pursuant to |
655 | subparagraph 1. |
656 | 4. If the board determines that the factual requirements |
657 | of subparagraph 1. are met, it shall take disciplinary action as |
658 | it deems appropriate against the licensee. Such disciplinary |
659 | action shall include, at a minimum, probation of the license |
660 | with the restriction that the licensee must make payments to the |
661 | judgment creditor on a schedule determined by the board to be |
662 | reasonable and within the financial capability of the |
663 | osteopathic physician. Notwithstanding any other disciplinary |
664 | penalty imposed, the disciplinary penalty may include suspension |
665 | of the license for a period not to exceed 5 years. In the event |
666 | that an agreement to satisfy a judgment has been met, the board |
667 | shall remove any restriction on the license. |
668 | 5. The licensee has completed a form supplying necessary |
669 | information as required by the department. |
670 |
|
671 | A licensee who meets the requirements of this paragraph shall be |
672 | required either to post notice in the form of a sign prominently |
673 | displayed in the reception area and clearly noticeable by all |
674 | patients or to provide a written statement to any person to whom |
675 | medical services are being provided. Such sign or statement |
676 | shall state: "Under Florida law, osteopathic physicians are |
677 | generally required to carry medical malpractice insurance or |
678 | otherwise demonstrate financial responsibility to cover |
679 | potential claims for medical malpractice. YOUR OSTEOPATHIC |
680 | PHYSICIAN HAS DECIDED NOT TO CARRY MEDICAL MALPRACTICE |
681 | INSURANCE. This is permitted under Florida law subject to |
682 | certain conditions. Florida law imposes strict penalties against |
683 | noninsured osteopathic physicians who fail to satisfy adverse |
684 | judgments arising from claims of medical malpractice. This |
685 | notice is provided pursuant to Florida law." In addition, a |
686 | licensee who meets the requirements of this paragraph and who is |
687 | covered for claims of medical negligence arising from care and |
688 | treatment of patients in a hospital that assumes sole and |
689 | exclusive liability for all such claims pursuant to an |
690 | enterprise plan for patient protection and provider liability |
691 | under ss. 766.401-766.409, shall post notice in the form of a |
692 | sign prominently displayed in the reception area and clearly |
693 | noticeable by all patients or provide a written statement to any |
694 | person for whom the osteopathic physician may provide medical |
695 | care and treatment in any such hospital. The sign or statement |
696 | must adhere to the requirements of s. 766.404. |
697 | Section 6. Section 627.41485, Florida Statutes, is created |
698 | to read: |
699 | 627.41485 Medical malpractice insurers; optional coverage |
700 | exclusion for insureds who are covered by an enterprise plan for |
701 | patient protection and provider liability.-- |
702 | (1) An insurer issuing policies of professional liability |
703 | coverage for claims arising out of the rendering of, or the |
704 | failure to render, medical care or services may make available |
705 | to physicians licensed under chapter 458 and to osteopathic |
706 | physicians licensed under chapter 459 coverage having an |
707 | appropriate exclusion for acts of medical negligence occurring |
708 | within: |
709 | (a) A certified patient safety facility that bears sole |
710 | and exclusive liability for acts of medical negligence pursuant |
711 | to the Enterprise Act for Patient Protection and Provider |
712 | Liability, inclusive of ss. 766.401-766.409, subject to the |
713 | usual underwriting standards; or |
714 | (b) A statutory teaching hospital that has agreed to |
715 | indemnify the physician or osteopathic physician for legal |
716 | liability pursuant to s. 766.110(2)(c), subject to the usual |
717 | underwriting standards. |
718 | (2) The Department of Financial Services may adopt rules |
719 | to administer this section. |
720 | Section 7. Section 766.316, Florida Statutes, is amended |
721 | to read: |
722 | 766.316 Notice to obstetrical patients of participation in |
723 | the plan.--Each hospital with a participating physician on its |
724 | staff, each hospital that assumes liability for affected |
725 | physicians pursuant to the Enterprise Act for Patient Protection |
726 | and Provider Liability, inclusive of ss. 766.401-766.409, and |
727 | each participating physician, other than residents, assistant |
728 | residents, and interns deemed to be participating physicians |
729 | under s. 766.314(4)(c), under the Florida Birth-Related |
730 | Neurological Injury Compensation Plan shall provide notice to |
731 | the obstetrical patients as to the limited no-fault alternative |
732 | for birth-related neurological injuries. Such notice shall be |
733 | provided on forms furnished by the association and shall include |
734 | a clear and concise explanation of a patient's rights and |
735 | limitations under the plan. The hospital or the participating |
736 | physician may elect to have the patient sign a form |
737 | acknowledging receipt of the notice form. Signature of the |
738 | patient acknowledging receipt of the notice form raises a |
739 | rebuttable presumption that the notice requirements of this |
740 | section have been met. Notice need not be given to a patient |
741 | when the patient has an emergency medical condition as defined |
742 | in s. 395.002(9)(b) or when notice is not practicable. |
743 | Section 8. Subsection (2) of section 766.110, Florida |
744 | Statutes, is amended to read: |
745 | 766.110 Liability of health care facilities.-- |
746 | (2)(a) Every hospital licensed under chapter 395 may carry |
747 | liability insurance or adequately insure itself in an amount of |
748 | not less than $1.5 million per claim, $5 million annual |
749 | aggregate to cover all medical injuries to patients resulting |
750 | from negligent acts or omissions on the part of those members of |
751 | its medical staff who are covered thereby in furtherance of the |
752 | requirements of ss. 458.320 and 459.0085. Self-insurance |
753 | coverage extended hereunder to a member of a hospital's medical |
754 | staff meets the financial responsibility requirements of ss. |
755 | 458.320 and 459.0085 if the physician's coverage limits are not |
756 | less than the minimum limits established in ss. 458.320 and |
757 | 459.0085 and the hospital is a verified trauma center that has |
758 | extended self-insurance coverage continuously to members of its |
759 | medical staff for activities both inside and outside of the |
760 | hospital. Any insurer authorized to write casualty insurance may |
761 | make available, but is shall not be required to write, such |
762 | coverage. The hospital may assess on an equitable and pro rata |
763 | basis the following professional health care providers for a |
764 | portion of the total hospital insurance cost for this coverage: |
765 | physicians licensed under chapter 458, osteopathic physicians |
766 | licensed under chapter 459, podiatric physicians licensed under |
767 | chapter 461, dentists licensed under chapter 466, and nurses |
768 | licensed under part I of chapter 464. The hospital may provide |
769 | for a deductible amount to be applied against any individual |
770 | health care provider found liable in a law suit in tort or for |
771 | breach of contract. The legislative intent in providing for the |
772 | deductible to be applied to individual health care providers |
773 | found negligent or in breach of contract is to instill in each |
774 | individual health care provider the incentive to avoid the risk |
775 | of injury to the fullest extent and ensure that the citizens of |
776 | this state receive the highest quality health care obtainable. |
777 | (b) Except with regard to hospitals that receive sovereign |
778 | immunity under s. 768.28, each hospital licensed under chapter |
779 | 395 which assumes sole and exclusive liability for acts of |
780 | medical negligence by affected providers pursuant to the |
781 | Enterprise Act for Patient Protection and Provider Liability, |
782 | inclusive of ss. 766.401-766.409, shall carry liability |
783 | insurance or adequately insure itself in an amount not less than |
784 | $2.5 million per claim, $7.5 million annual aggregate to cover |
785 | all medical injuries to patients resulting from negligent acts |
786 | or omissions on the part of affected physicians and |
787 | practitioners who are covered by an enterprise plan for patient |
788 | protection and provider liability. The hospital's policy of |
789 | medical liability insurance or self-insurance must satisfy the |
790 | financial responsibility requirements of ss. 458.320(2) and |
791 | 459.0085(2) for affected providers. Any authorized insurer as |
792 | defined in s. 626.914(2), risk retention group as defined in s. |
793 | 627.942, or joint underwriting association established under s. |
794 | 627.351(4) that has authority to write casualty insurance may |
795 | make available, but is not required to write, such coverage. |
796 | (c) Notwithstanding any provision in the Insurance Code to |
797 | the contrary, a statutory teaching hospital, as defined in s. |
798 | 408.07, other than a hospital that receives sovereign immunity |
799 | under s. 768.28, which complies with the patient safety measures |
800 | specified in s. 766.403 and all other requirements of s. |
801 | 766.409, including approval by the Agency for Health Care |
802 | Administration, may agree to indemnify some or all members of |
803 | its medical staff, including, but not limited to, physicians |
804 | having clinical privileges who are not employees or agents of |
805 | the hospital and any organization, association, or group of |
806 | persons liable for the negligent acts of such physicians, |
807 | whether incorporated or unincorporated, and some or all medical, |
808 | nursing, or allied health students affiliated with the hospital, |
809 | collectively known as covered persons, other than persons exempt |
810 | from liability due to sovereign immunity under s. 768.28, for |
811 | legal liability of such covered persons for loss, damages, or |
812 | expense arising out of medical negligence within the hospital |
813 | premises, as defined in s. 766.401, thereby providing limited |
814 | malpractice coverage for such covered persons. Any hospital that |
815 | agrees to provide malpractice coverage for covered persons under |
816 | this section shall acquire an appropriate policy of professional |
817 | liability insurance or establish and maintain a fund from which |
818 | such malpractice coverage is provided, in accordance with usual |
819 | underwriting standards. Such insurance or fund may be separate |
820 | and apart from any insurance or fund maintained by or on behalf |
821 | of the hospital or combined in a single policy of insurance or a |
822 | fund maintained by or on behalf of the hospital. Any hospital |
823 | that provides malpractice coverage to covered persons as defined |
824 | in this paragraph through a fund providing any such malpractice |
825 | coverage, shall annually provide a certified financial statement |
826 | containing actuarial projections as to the soundness of reserves |
827 | to the Agency for Health Care Administration. The indemnity |
828 | agreements or malpractice coverage provided by this section |
829 | shall be in amounts that, at a minimum, meet the financial |
830 | responsibility requirements of ss. 458.320 and 459.0085 for |
831 | affected providers. Any such indemnity agreement or malpractice |
832 | coverage in such amounts satisfies the financial responsibility |
833 | requirements of ss. 458.320 and 459.0085 for affected providers. |
834 | Any statutory teaching hospital that agrees to indemnify |
835 | physicians or other covered persons for medical negligence on |
836 | the premises pursuant to this section may charge such physicians |
837 | or other covered persons a reasonable fee for malpractice |
838 | coverage, notwithstanding any provision in the Insurance Code to |
839 | the contrary. Such fee shall be based on appropriate actuarial |
840 | criteria. This paragraph does not constitute a waiver of |
841 | sovereign immunity under s. 768.28. Nothing in this subsection |
842 | impairs a hospital's ability to indemnify member of its medical |
843 | staff to the extent such indemnification is allowed by law. |
844 | Section 9. Section 766.401, Florida Statutes, is created |
845 | to read: |
846 | 766.401 Definitions.--As used in this section and ss. |
847 | 766.402-766.409, the term: |
848 | (1) "Affected facility" means a certified patient safety |
849 | facility. |
850 | (2) "Affected patient" means a patient of a certified |
851 | patient safety facility. |
852 | (3) "Affected physician" means a medical staff member who |
853 | is covered by an enterprise plan for patient protection and |
854 | provider liability in a certified patient safety facility. |
855 | (4) "Affected practitioner" means any person, including a |
856 | physician, who is credentialed by the eligible hospital to |
857 | provide health care services who is covered by an enterprise |
858 | plan for patient protection and provider liability in a |
859 | certified patient safety facility. |
860 | (5) "Agency" means the Agency for Health Care |
861 | Administration. |
862 | (6) "Certified patient safety facility" means any eligible |
863 | hospital that is solely and exclusively liable for the medical |
864 | negligence within the licensed facility in accordance with an |
865 | agency order approving an enterprise plan for patient protection |
866 | and provider liability, except that for an eligible hospital |
867 | meeting the requirements of s. 768.28(12)(c)3., such hospital |
868 | shall be solely and exclusively liable for the medical |
869 | negligence of affected practitioners who are employees and |
870 | agents of a state university and the employees and agents of the |
871 | hospital. |
872 | (7) "Clinical privileges" means the privileges granted to |
873 | a physician or other licensed health care practitioner to render |
874 | patient care services in a hospital. |
875 | (8) "Eligible hospital" or "licensed facility" means: |
876 | (a) A statutory teaching hospital as defined by s. 408.07; |
877 | or |
878 | (b) A hospital licensed in accordance with chapter 395 |
879 | which is wholly owned by a university based in this state which |
880 | maintains an accredited medical school. |
881 | (9) "Enterprise plan" means a document adopted by the |
882 | governing board of an eligible hospital and the executive |
883 | committee of the medical staff of the eligible hospital, however |
884 | defined, or the board of trustees of a state university, |
885 | manifesting concurrence and setting forth certain rights, |
886 | duties, privileges, obligations, and responsibilities of the |
887 | health care facility and its medical staff, or its affiliated |
888 | medical school, in furtherance of seeking and maintaining status |
889 | as a certified patient safety facility. |
890 | (10) "Health care provider" or "provider" means: |
891 | (a) An eligible hospital. |
892 | (b) A physician or physician assistant licensed under |
893 | chapter 458. |
894 | (c) An osteopathic physician or osteopathic physician |
895 | assistant licensed under chapter 459. |
896 | (d) A registered nurse, nurse midwife, licensed practical |
897 | nurse, or advanced registered nurse practitioner licensed or |
898 | registered under part I of chapter 464 or any facility that |
899 | employs nurses licensed or registered under part I of chapter |
900 | 464 to supply all or part of the care delivered by that |
901 | facility. |
902 | (e) A health care professional association and its |
903 | employees or a corporate medical group and its employees. |
904 | (f) Any other medical facility the primary purpose of |
905 | which is to deliver human medical diagnostic services or which |
906 | delivers nonsurgical human medical treatment, including an |
907 | office maintained by a provider. |
908 | (g) A free clinic that delivers only medical diagnostic |
909 | services or nonsurgical medical treatment free of charge to all |
910 | low-income recipients. |
911 | (h) Any other health care professional, practitioner, or |
912 | provider, including a student enrolled in an accredited program |
913 | that prepares the student for licensure as any one of the |
914 | professionals listed in this subsection. |
915 |
|
916 | The term includes any person, organization, or entity that is |
917 | vicariously liable under the theory of respondent superior or |
918 | any other theory of legal liability for medical negligence |
919 | committed by any licensed professional listed in this |
920 | subsection. The term also includes any nonprofit corporation |
921 | qualified as exempt from federal income taxation under s. 501(a) |
922 | of the Internal Revenue Code, and described in s. 501(c) of the |
923 | Internal Revenue Code, including any university or medical |
924 | school that employs licensed professionals listed in this |
925 | subsection or that delivers health care services provided by |
926 | licensed professionals listed in this subsection, any federally |
927 | funded community health center, and any volunteer corporation or |
928 | volunteer health care provider that delivers health care |
929 | services. |
930 | (11) "Health care practitioner" or "practitioner" means |
931 | any person, entity, or organization identified in subsection |
932 | (9), except for a hospital. |
933 | (12) "Medical incident" or "adverse incident" has the same |
934 | meaning as provided in ss. 381.0271, 395.0197, 458.351, and |
935 | 459.026. |
936 | (13) "Medical negligence" means medical malpractice, |
937 | whether grounded in tort or in contract, including statutory |
938 | claims arising out of any act or omission relating to the |
939 | rendering or failure to render medical or nursing care. The term |
940 | does not include intentional acts. |
941 | (14) "Medical staff" means a physician licensed under |
942 | chapter 458 or chapter 459 having clinical privileges and active |
943 | status in a licensed facility. The term includes any affected |
944 | physician. |
945 | (15) "Person" means any individual, partnership, |
946 | corporation, association, or governmental unit. |
947 | (16) "Premises" means those buildings, beds, and equipment |
948 | located at the address of the licensed facility and all other |
949 | buildings, beds, and equipment for the provision of hospital, |
950 | ambulatory surgical, mobile surgical care, primary care, or |
951 | comprehensive health care under the dominion and control of the |
952 | licensee, including offices and locations where the licensed |
953 | facility provides medical care and treatment to affected |
954 | patients. |
955 | (17) "Statutory teaching hospital" or "teaching hospital" |
956 | has the same meaning as provided in s. 408.07. |
957 | (18) "Within the licensed facility" or "within the |
958 | premises" means anywhere on the premises of the licensed |
959 | facility or the premises of any office, clinic, or ancillary |
960 | facility that is owned or leased or controlled by the licensed |
961 | facility. |
962 | Section 10. Section 766.402, Florida Statutes, is created |
963 | to read: |
964 | 766.402 Agency approval of enterprise plans for patient |
965 | protection and provider liability.-- |
966 | (1) An eligible hospital in conjunction with the executive |
967 | committee of its medical staff or the board of trustees of a |
968 | state university, if applicable, that has adopted an enterprise |
969 | plan may petition the agency to enter an order certifying |
970 | approval of the hospital as a certified patient safety facility. |
971 | (2) In accordance with chapter 120, the agency shall enter |
972 | an order certifying approval of the certified patient safety |
973 | facility upon a showing that, in furtherance of an enterprise |
974 | approach to patient protection and provider liability: |
975 | (a) The petitioners have established enterprise-wide |
976 | safety measures for the care and treatment of patients. |
977 | (b) The petitioners satisfy requirements for patient |
978 | protection measures, as specified in s. 766.403. |
979 | (c) The petitioners acknowledge and agree to enterprise |
980 | liability for medical negligence within the premises, as |
981 | specified in s. 766.404. |
982 | (d) The petitioners have adopted an enterprise plan, as |
983 | specified in s. 766.405. |
984 | (e) The petitioners satisfy requirements for professional |
985 | accountability of affected practitioners, as specified in s. |
986 | 766.406. |
987 | (f) The petitioners satisfy requirements for financial |
988 | accountability of affected practitioners, as specified in s. |
989 | 766.407. |
990 | (g) The petitioners satisfy all other requirements of ss. |
991 | 766.401-766.409. |
992 | Section 11. Section 766.403, Florida Statutes, is created |
993 | to read: |
994 | 766.403 Enterprise-wide patient safety measures.-- |
995 | (1) In order to satisfy the requirements of s. |
996 | 766.402(2)(a) or s. 766.409, the licensed facility shall: |
997 | (a) Have in place a process, either through the facility's |
998 | patient safety committee or a similar body, for coordinating the |
999 | quality control, risk management, and patient relations |
1000 | functions of the facility and for reporting to the facility's |
1001 | governing board at least quarterly regarding such efforts. |
1002 | (b) Establish within the facility a system for reporting |
1003 | near misses and agree to submit any information collected to the |
1004 | Florida Patient Safety Corporation. Such information must be |
1005 | submitted by the facility and made available by the Patient |
1006 | Safety Corporation in accordance with s. 381.0271(7). |
1007 | (c) Design and make available to facility staff, including |
1008 | medical staff, a patient safety curriculum that provides lecture |
1009 | and web-based training on recognized patient safety principles, |
1010 | which may include communication skills training, team |
1011 | performance assessment and training, risk prevention strategies, |
1012 | and best practices and evidence based medicine. The licensed |
1013 | facility shall report annually to the agency the programs |
1014 | presented. |
1015 | (d) Implement a program to identify health care providers |
1016 | on the facility's staff who may be eligible for an early- |
1017 | intervention program providing additional skills assessment and |
1018 | training and offer such training to the staff on a voluntary and |
1019 | confidential basis with established mechanisms to assess program |
1020 | performance and results. |
1021 | (e) Implement a simulation-based program for skills |
1022 | assessment, training, and retraining of a facility's staff in |
1023 | those tasks and activities that the agency identifies by rule. |
1024 | (f) Designate a patient advocate who coordinates with |
1025 | members of the medical staff and the facility's chief medical |
1026 | officer regarding disclosure of medical incidents to patients. |
1027 | In addition, the patient advocate shall establish an advisory |
1028 | panel, consisting of providers, patients or their families, and |
1029 | other health care consumer or consumer groups to review general |
1030 | patient safety concerns and other issues related to relations |
1031 | among and between patients and providers and to identify areas |
1032 | where additional education and program development may be |
1033 | appropriate. |
1034 | (g) Establish a procedure to biennially review the |
1035 | facility's patient safety program and its compliance with the |
1036 | requirements of this section. Such review shall be conducted by |
1037 | an independent patient safety organization as defined in s. |
1038 | 766.1016(1) or other professional organization approved by the |
1039 | agency. The organization performing the review shall prepare a |
1040 | written report with detailed findings and recommendations. The |
1041 | report shall be forwarded to the facility's risk manager or |
1042 | patient safety officer, who may make written comments in |
1043 | response thereto. The report and any written comments shall be |
1044 | presented to the governing board of the licensed facility. A |
1045 | copy of the report and any of the facilities' responses to the |
1046 | findings and recommendations shall be provided to the agency |
1047 | within 60 days after the date that the governing board reviewed |
1048 | the report. The report is confidential and exempt from |
1049 | production or discovery in any civil action. Likewise, the |
1050 | report, and the information contained therein, is not admissible |
1051 | as evidence for any purpose in any action for medical |
1052 | negligence. |
1053 | (h) Establish a system for the trending and tracking of |
1054 | quality and patient safety indicators that the agency may |
1055 | identify by rule, and a method for review of the data at least |
1056 | semiannually by the facility's patient safety committee. |
1057 | (i) Provide assistance to affected physicians, upon |
1058 | request, regarding implementation and evaluation of individual |
1059 | risk-management, patient-safety, and incident-reporting systems |
1060 | in clinical settings outside the premises of the licensed |
1061 | facility. Provision of such assistance may not be the basis for |
1062 | finding or imposing any liability on the licensed facility for |
1063 | acts or omissions of the affected physicians in clinical |
1064 | settings outside the premises of the licensed facility. |
1065 | (2) This section does not constitute an applicable |
1066 | standard of care in any action for medical negligence or |
1067 | otherwise create a private right of action, and evidence of |
1068 | noncompliance with this section is not admissible for any |
1069 | purpose in any action for medical negligence against an affected |
1070 | facility or any other health care provider. |
1071 | (3) This section does not prohibit the licensed facility |
1072 | from implementing other measures for promoting patient safety |
1073 | within the premises. This section does not relieve the licensed |
1074 | facility from the duty to implement any other patient safety |
1075 | measure that is required by state law. The Legislature intends |
1076 | that the patient safety measures specified in this section are |
1077 | in addition to all other patient safety measures required by |
1078 | state law, federal law, and applicable accreditation standards |
1079 | for licensed facilities. |
1080 | (4) A review, report, or other document created, produced, |
1081 | delivered, or discussed pursuant to this section is not |
1082 | discoverable or admissible as evidence in any legal action. |
1083 | Section 12. Section 766.404, Florida Statutes, is created |
1084 | to read: |
1085 | 766.404 Enterprise liability in certain health care |
1086 | facilities.-- |
1087 | (1) Subject to the requirements of ss. 766.401-766.409, |
1088 | the agency may enter an order certifying the petitioner-hospital |
1089 | as a certified patient safety facility and providing that the |
1090 | hospital bears sole and exclusive liability for any and all acts |
1091 | of medical negligence within the licensed facility when such |
1092 | acts of medical negligence within the premises cause damage to |
1093 | affected patients, including, but not limited to, acts of |
1094 | medical negligence by physicians or other licensed health care |
1095 | providers who exercise clinical privileges in a licensed |
1096 | hospital, whether or not the active tortfeasor is an employee or |
1097 | agent of the health care facility when the incident of medical |
1098 | negligence occurred, except that for petitioner hospitals |
1099 | meeting the requirements of s. 768.28(12)(c)3., enterprise |
1100 | liability shall be limited to apply to affected practitioners |
1101 | who are employees or agents of a state university and the |
1102 | employees and agents of the hospital. |
1103 | (2) In any action for personal injury or wrongful death, |
1104 | whether in contract or tort or predicated upon a statutory cause |
1105 | of action, arising out of medical negligence within the premises |
1106 | resulting in damages to a patient of a certified patient safety |
1107 | facility, the licensed facility bears sole and exclusive |
1108 | liability for medical negligence, whether or not the |
1109 | practitioner was an employee or agent of the facility when the |
1110 | incident of medical negligence occurred, except that for |
1111 | petitioner hospitals meeting the requirements of s. |
1112 | 768.28(12)(c)3., enterprise liability shall be limited to apply |
1113 | to affected practitioners who are employees or agents of a state |
1114 | university and the employees and agents of the hospital. Any |
1115 | other provider, person, organization, or entity that commits |
1116 | medical negligence within the premises resulting in damages to a |
1117 | patient, and any other provider, person, organization, or entity |
1118 | that is vicariously liable for medical negligence within the |
1119 | premises of an affected practitioner under the theory of |
1120 | respondent superior or otherwise, may not be named as a |
1121 | defendant in any such action and any such provider, person, |
1122 | organization, or entity is not liable for the medical negligence |
1123 | of an affected practitioner. This subsection does not impose |
1124 | liability or confer immunity on any other provider, person, |
1125 | organization, or entity for acts of medical malpractice |
1126 | committed on any person in clinical settings other than the |
1127 | premises of the affected facility. |
1128 | (3) An affected practitioner shall post an applicable |
1129 | notice or provide an appropriate written statement as follows: |
1130 | (a) An affected practitioner shall post notice in the form |
1131 | of a sign prominently displayed in the reception area and |
1132 | clearly noticeable by all patients or provide a written |
1133 | statement to any person to whom medical services are being |
1134 | provided. The sign or statement must read as follows: "In |
1135 | general, physicians in the State of Florida are personally |
1136 | liable for acts of medical negligence, subject to certain |
1137 | limitations. However, physicians who perform medical services |
1138 | within a certified patient safety facility are exempt from |
1139 | personal liability because the licensed hospital bears sole and |
1140 | exclusive liability for acts of medical negligence within the |
1141 | health care facility pursuant to an administrative order of the |
1142 | Agency for Health Care Administration entered in accordance with |
1143 | the Enterprise Act for Patient Protection and Provider |
1144 | Liability. YOUR DOCTOR HOLDS CLINICAL STAFF PRIVILEGES IN A |
1145 | CERTIFIED PATIENT SAFETY FACILITY. UNDER FLORIDA LAW, ANY CLAIM |
1146 | FOR MEDICAL NEGLIGENCE WITHIN THE HEALTH CARE FACILITY MUST BE |
1147 | INITIATED AGAINST THE HOSPITAL AND NOT AGAINST YOUR DOCTOR, |
1148 | BECAUSE THE HOSPITAL IS SOLELY RESPONSIBLE FOR ALL ACTS OF |
1149 | PROFESSIONAL NEGLIGENCE WITHIN THE PREMISES. THIS PROVISION DOES |
1150 | NOT AFFECT YOUR PHYSICIAN'S LIABILITY FOR ACTS OF MEDICAL |
1151 | NEGLIGENCE IN OTHER CLINICAL SETTINGS. IF YOU DO NOT UNDERSTAND, |
1152 | PLEASE DISCUSS WITH YOUR DOCTOR BEFORE YOUR CONSULTATION. This |
1153 | notice is provided pursuant to Florida law." |
1154 | (b) If an affected practitioner is covered by an |
1155 | enterprise plan for patient protection and provider liability in |
1156 | one or more licensed facilities that receive sovereign immunity, |
1157 | and one or more other licensed facilities, the affected |
1158 | practitioner shall post notice in the form of a sign prominently |
1159 | displayed in the reception area and clearly noticeable by all |
1160 | patients or provide a written statement to any person to whom |
1161 | medical services are being provided. The sign or statement must |
1162 | read as follows: "In general, physicians in the state of Florida |
1163 | are personally liable for acts of medical negligence, subject to |
1164 | certain limitations such as sovereign immunity. However, |
1165 | physicians who perform medical services within a certified |
1166 | patient safety facility are exempt from personal liability |
1167 | because the licensed hospital bears sole and exclusive liability |
1168 | for acts of medical negligence within the affected facility |
1169 | pursuant to an administrative order of the Agency for Health |
1170 | Care Administration entered in accordance with the Enterprise |
1171 | Act for Patient Protection and Provider Liability. YOUR DOCTOR |
1172 | HOLDS CLINICAL STAFF PRIVILEGES IN ONE OR MORE CERTIFIED PATIENT |
1173 | SAFETY FACILITIES. AT LEAST ONE OF THESE HOSPITALS IS SUBJECT TO |
1174 | SOVEREIGN IMMUNITY. UNDER FLORIDA LAW, ANY CLAIM FOR MEDICAL |
1175 | NEGLIGENCE WITHIN THE HEALTH CARE FACILITY MUST BE INITIATED |
1176 | AGAINST THE HOSPITAL AND NOT AGAINST YOUR DOCTOR, BECAUSE THE |
1177 | HOSPITAL IS SOLELY RESPONSIBLE FOR ALL ACTS OF PROFESSIONAL |
1178 | NEGLIGENCE WITHIN THE PREMISES. MOREOVER, RECOVERY AGAINST THE |
1179 | HOSPITAL MAY BE LIMITED, DUE TO FLORIDA'S SOVEREIGN IMMUNITY |
1180 | LAW. THESE PROVISIONS DO NOT AFFECT YOUR PHYSICIAN'S LIABILITY |
1181 | FOR ACTS OF MEDICAL NEGLIGENCE IN OTHER CLINICAL SETTINGS. IF |
1182 | YOU DO NOT UNDERSTAND, PLEASE DISCUSS WITH YOUR DOCTOR BEFORE |
1183 | YOUR CONSULTATION. This notice is provided pursuant to Florida |
1184 | law." |
1185 | (c) Notice need not be given to a patient when: |
1186 | 1. The patient has an emergency medical condition as |
1187 | defined in s. 395.002; |
1188 | 2. The practitioner is an employee or agent of a |
1189 | governmental entity and is immune from liability and suit under |
1190 | s. 768.28; or |
1191 | 3. Notice is not practicable. |
1192 | (d) This subsection is directory in nature. An agency |
1193 | order certifying approval of an enterprise plan for patient |
1194 | protection and provider liability shall, as a matter of law, |
1195 | constitute conclusive evidence that the hospital complies with |
1196 | all applicable patient safety requirements of s. 766.403 and all |
1197 | other requirements of ss. 766.401-766.409. Evidence of |
1198 | noncompliance with s. 766.403 or any other provision of ss. |
1199 | 766.401-766.409 may not be admissible for any purpose in any |
1200 | action for medical malpractice. Failure to comply with the |
1201 | requirements of this subsection does not affect the liabilities |
1202 | or immunities conferred by ss. 766.401-766.409. This subsection |
1203 | does not give rise to an independent cause of action for |
1204 | damages. |
1205 | (4) The agency order certifying approval of an enterprise |
1206 | plan for patient protection and provider liability applies |
1207 | prospectively to causes of action for medical negligence that |
1208 | arise on or after the effective date of the order. |
1209 | (5) Upon entry of an order approving the petition, the |
1210 | agency may conduct onsite examinations of the licensed facility |
1211 | to assure continued compliance with the terms and conditions of |
1212 | the order. |
1213 | (6) The agency order certifying approval of an enterprise |
1214 | plan for patient protection remains in effect until revoked. The |
1215 | agency shall revoke the order upon the unilateral request of the |
1216 | licensed facility, the executive committee of the medical staff, |
1217 | or the affiliated medical school, whichever is applicable. The |
1218 | agency may revoke the order upon reasonable notice to the |
1219 | affected facility that it fails to comply with material |
1220 | requirements of ss. 766.401-766.409 or material conditions of |
1221 | the order certifying approval of the enterprise plan and further |
1222 | upon a determination that the licensed facility has failed to |
1223 | cure stated deficiencies upon reasonable notice. An |
1224 | administrative order revoking approval of an enterprise plan for |
1225 | patient protection and provider liability terminates the plan on |
1226 | January 1 of the year following entry of the order or 6 months |
1227 | after entry of the order, whichever is longer. Revocation of an |
1228 | agency order certifying approval of an enterprise plan for |
1229 | patient protection and provider liability applies prospectively |
1230 | to causes of action for medical negligence which arise on or |
1231 | after the effective date of the termination. |
1232 | (7) This section does not exempt a licensed facility from |
1233 | liability for acts of medical negligence committed by employees |
1234 | and agents thereof; although employees and agents of a certified |
1235 | patient safety facility may not be joined as defendants in any |
1236 | action for medical negligence because the licensed facility |
1237 | bears sole and exclusive liability for acts of medical |
1238 | negligence within the premises of the licensed facility, |
1239 | including acts of medical negligence by such employees and |
1240 | agents. |
1241 | (8) Affected practitioners shall cooperate in good faith |
1242 | with an affected facility in the investigation and defense of |
1243 | any claim for medical negligence. An affected facility shall |
1244 | have a cause of action for damages against an affected |
1245 | practitioner for bad faith refusal to cooperate in the |
1246 | investigation and defense of any claim of medical malpractice |
1247 | against the licensed facility. |
1248 | (9) Sections 766.401-766.409 do not impose strict |
1249 | liability or liability without fault for medical incidents that |
1250 | occur within an affected facility. To maintain a cause of action |
1251 | against an affected facility pursuant to ss. 766.401-766.409, |
1252 | the claimant must allege and prove that an employee or agent of |
1253 | the licensed facility, or an affected practitioner who is |
1254 | covered by an approved enterprise plan for patient protection |
1255 | and provider liability, committed medical negligence within the |
1256 | premises of the licensed facility which constitutes medical |
1257 | negligence under state law, even though an active tortfeasor is |
1258 | not named or joined as a party defendant in the lawsuit. |
1259 | (10) Sections 766.401-766.409 do not create an independent |
1260 | cause of action against any health care provider and do not |
1261 | impose enterprise liability on any health care provider, except |
1262 | as expressly provided, and may not be construed to support any |
1263 | cause of action other than an action for medical negligence as |
1264 | expressly provided against any person, organization, or entity. |
1265 | (11) Sections 766.401-766.409 do not waive sovereign |
1266 | immunity, except as expressly provided in s. 768.28. |
1267 | Section 13. Section 766.405, Florida Statutes, is created |
1268 | to read: |
1269 | 766.405 Enterprise plans.-- |
1270 | (1) It is the intent of the Legislature that enterprise |
1271 | plans for patient protection are elective and not mandatory for |
1272 | eligible hospitals. It is further the intent of the Legislature |
1273 | that the medical staff or affiliated medical school of an |
1274 | eligible hospital must concur with the development and |
1275 | implementation of an enterprise plan for patient protection and |
1276 | provider liability. It is further the intent of the Legislature |
1277 | that the licensed facility and medical staff or affiliated |
1278 | medical school be accorded wide latitude in formulating |
1279 | enterprise plans consistent with the underlying purpose of ss. |
1280 | 766.401-766.409 to encourage innovative, systemic measures for |
1281 | patient protection and quality assurance in licensed facilities, |
1282 | especially in clinical settings where surgery is performed. |
1283 | Adoption of an enterprise plan is a necessary condition for |
1284 | agency approval of an enterprise plan for a certified patient |
1285 | safety facility. |
1286 | (2) An eligible hospital and the executive committee of |
1287 | its medical staff of the board of trustees of a state |
1288 | university, if applicable, shall adopt an enterprise plan as a |
1289 | necessary condition to agency approval of a certified patient |
1290 | safety facility. An affirmative vote of approval by the |
1291 | regularly constituted executive committee of the medical staff, |
1292 | however named or constituted, is sufficient to manifest approval |
1293 | by the medical staff of the enterprise plan. Once approved, |
1294 | affected practitioners are subject to the enterprise plan. The |
1295 | plan may be conditioned on agency approval of an enterprise plan |
1296 | for patient protection and provider liability for the affected |
1297 | facility. For eligible hospitals meeting the requirements of s. |
1298 | 768.28(12)(c)3., the enterprise plan shall be limited to |
1299 | affective practitioners who are also employees or agents of a |
1300 | state university and employees and agents of the hospital. At a |
1301 | minimum, the enterprise plan must contain provisions covering: |
1302 | (a) Compliance with a patient protection plan. |
1303 | (b) Internal review of medical incidents. |
1304 | (c) Timely reporting of medical incidents to state |
1305 | agencies. |
1306 | (d) Professional accountability of affected practitioners. |
1307 | (e) Financial accountability of affected practitioners. |
1308 | (3) This section does not prohibit a patient safety |
1309 | facility from including other provisions in the enterprise plan, |
1310 | in a separate agreement, as a condition of staff privileges, or |
1311 | by way of contract with an organization providing medical staff |
1312 | for the licensed facility. |
1313 | (4) This section does not limit the power of any licensed |
1314 | facility to enter into other agreements with members of its |
1315 | medical staff or otherwise to impose restrictions, requirements, |
1316 | or conditions on clinical privileges, as authorized by law. |
1317 | (5) If multiple campuses of a licensed facility share a |
1318 | license, the enterprise plan may be limited to the primary |
1319 | campus or the campus with the largest number of beds and, if |
1320 | applicable, associated outpatient ancillary facilities. If the |
1321 | enterprise plan is so limited, the plan must specify the campus |
1322 | and, if applicable, the ancillary facilities that will |
1323 | constitute the enterprise. |
1324 | Section 14. Section 766.406, Florida Statutes, is created |
1325 | to read: |
1326 | 766.406 Professional accountability of affected |
1327 | practitioners.-- |
1328 | (1) A certified patient safety facility shall report |
1329 | medical incidents occurring in the affected facility to the |
1330 | Department of Health, in accordance with s. 395.0197. |
1331 | (2) A certified patient safety facility shall report |
1332 | adverse findings of medical negligence or failure to adhere to |
1333 | applicable standards of professional responsibility by affected |
1334 | practitioners to the Department of Health. |
1335 | (3) A certified patient safety facility shall continue to |
1336 | perform all peer review functions pursuant to s. 395.0193. |
1337 | Section 15. Section 766.407, Florida Statutes, is created |
1338 | to read: |
1339 | 766.407 Financial accountability of affected |
1340 | practitioners.-- |
1341 | (1) An enterprise plan may provide that any affected |
1342 | member of the medical staff or any affected practitioner having |
1343 | clinical privileges, other than an employee of the licensed |
1344 | facility, and any organization that contracts with the licensed |
1345 | facility to provide practitioners to treat patients within the |
1346 | licensed facility, shall share equitably in the cost of omnibus |
1347 | medical liability insurance premiums covering the certified |
1348 | patient safety facility, similar self-insurance expense, or |
1349 | other expenses reasonably related to risk management and |
1350 | adjustment of claims of medical negligence. This subsection does |
1351 | not permit a licensed facility and any affected practitioner to |
1352 | agree on charges for an equitable share of medical liability |
1353 | expense based on the number of patients admitted to the hospital |
1354 | by individual practitioners, patient revenue for the licensed |
1355 | facility generated by individual practitioners, or overall |
1356 | profit or loss sustained by the certified patient safety |
1357 | facility in a given fiscal period. |
1358 | (2) Pursuant to an enterprise plan for patient protection |
1359 | and provider liability, a licensed facility may impose a |
1360 | reasonable assessment against an affected practitioner that |
1361 | commits medical negligence resulting in injury and damages to an |
1362 | affected patient of the health care facility, upon a |
1363 | determination of failure to adhere to acceptable standards of |
1364 | professional responsibility by an internal peer review |
1365 | committee. A schedule of assessments, criteria for the levying |
1366 | of assessments, procedures for levying assessments, and due |
1367 | process rights of an affected practitioner must be agreed to by |
1368 | the executive committee of the medical staff or affiliated |
1369 | medical school, as applicable, and the licensed facility. The |
1370 | legislative intent in providing for assessments against an |
1371 | affected physician is to instill in each individual health care |
1372 | practitioner the incentive to avoid the risk of injury to the |
1373 | fullest extent and ensure that the residents of this state |
1374 | receive the highest quality health care obtainable. Failure to |
1375 | pay an assessment constitutes grounds for suspension of clinical |
1376 | privileges by the licensed facility. Assessments may be enforced |
1377 | as bona fide debts in a court of law. The licensed facility may |
1378 | exempt its employees and agents from all such assessments. |
1379 | Employees and agents of the state, its agencies, and |
1380 | subdivisions, as defined by s. 768.28, are exempt from all such |
1381 | assessments. |
1382 | (3) An assessment levied pursuant to this section is not |
1383 | discoverable or admissible as evidence in any legal action. |
1384 | Section 16. Section 766.408, Florida Statutes, is created |
1385 | to read: |
1386 | 766.408 Data collection and reports.-- |
1387 | (1) Each certified patient safety facility shall submit an |
1388 | annual report to the agency containing information and data |
1389 | reasonably required by the agency to evaluate performance and |
1390 | effectiveness of the facility's enterprise plan for patient |
1391 | protection and provider liability. However, information may not |
1392 | be submitted or disclosed in violation of any patient's right to |
1393 | privacy under state or federal law. |
1394 | (2) The agency shall aggregate information and data |
1395 | submitted by all affected facilities and each year, on or before |
1396 | March 1, the agency shall submit a report to the Legislature |
1397 | that evaluates the performance and effectiveness of the |
1398 | enterprise approach to patient safety and provider liability in |
1399 | certified patient safety facilities, which reports must include, |
1400 | but are not limited to, pertinent data on: |
1401 | (a) The number and names of affected facilities; |
1402 | (b) The number and types of patient protection measures |
1403 | currently in effect in these facilities; |
1404 | (c) The number of affected practitioners; |
1405 | (d) The number of affected patients; |
1406 | (e) The number of surgical procedures by affected |
1407 | practitioners on affected patients; |
1408 | (f) The number of medical incidents, claims of medical |
1409 | malpractice, and claims resulting in indemnity; |
1410 | (g) The average time for resolution of contested and |
1411 | uncontested claims of medical malpractice; |
1412 | (h) The percentage of claims that result in civil trials; |
1413 | (i) The percentage of civil trials resulting in adverse |
1414 | judgments against affected facilities; |
1415 | (j) The number and average size of an indemnity paid to |
1416 | claimants; |
1417 | (k) The number and average size of assessments imposed on |
1418 | affected practitioners; |
1419 | (l) The estimated liability expense, inclusive of medical |
1420 | liability insurance premiums; and |
1421 | (m) The percentage of medical liability expense, inclusive |
1422 | of medical liability insurance premiums, which is borne by |
1423 | affected practitioners in affected health care facilities. |
1424 |
|
1425 | Such reports to the Legislature may also include other |
1426 | information and data that the agency deems appropriate to gauge |
1427 | the cost and benefit of enterprise plans for patient protection |
1428 | and provider liability. |
1429 | (3) The agency's annual report to the Legislature may |
1430 | include relevant information and data obtained from the Office |
1431 | of Insurance Regulation within the Department of Financial |
1432 | Services on the availability and affordability of enterprise- |
1433 | wide medical liability insurance coverage for affected |
1434 | facilities and the availability and affordability of insurance |
1435 | policies for individual practitioners which contain coverage |
1436 | exclusions for acts of medical negligence in certified patient |
1437 | safety facilities. The Office of Insurance Regulation within the |
1438 | Department of Financial Services shall cooperate with the agency |
1439 | in the reporting of information and data specified in this |
1440 | subsection. |
1441 | (4) Reports submitted to the agency by affected facilities |
1442 | pursuant to this section are public records under chapter 199. |
1443 | However, these reports, and the information contained therein, |
1444 | are not admissible as evidence in a court of law in any action. |
1445 | Section 17. Section 766.409, Florida Statutes, is created |
1446 | to read: |
1447 | 766.409 Damages in malpractice actions against certain |
1448 | hospitals that meet patient safety requirements; agency approval |
1449 | of patient safety measures.-- |
1450 | (1) In recognition of their essential role in training |
1451 | future health care providers and in providing innovative medical |
1452 | care for this state's residents, in recognition of their |
1453 | commitment to treating indigent patients, and further in |
1454 | recognition that all teaching hospitals, as defined in s. |
1455 | 408.07, both public and private, and hospitals licensed under |
1456 | chapter 395 which are owned and operated by a university that |
1457 | maintains an accredited medical school, collectively defined as |
1458 | eligible hospitals in s. 766.401(8), provide benefits to the |
1459 | residents of this state through their roles in improving the |
1460 | quality of medical care, training health care providers, and |
1461 | caring for indigent patients, the limits of liability for |
1462 | medical malpractice arising out of the rendering of, or the |
1463 | failure to render, medical care by all such hospitals, shall be |
1464 | determined in accordance with the requirements of this section, |
1465 | notwithstanding any other provision of state law. |
1466 | (2) Except as otherwise provided in subsections (9) and |
1467 | (10), any eligible hospital may petition the agency to enter an |
1468 | order certifying that the licensed facility complies with |
1469 | patient safety measures specified in s. 766.403. |
1470 | (3) In accordance with chapter 120, the agency shall enter |
1471 | an order approving the petition upon a showing that the eligible |
1472 | hospital complies with the patient safety measures specified in |
1473 | s. 766.403. Upon entry of the agency order, and for the entire |
1474 | period of time that the order remains in effect, the limits of |
1475 | liability for medical malpractice arising out of the rendering |
1476 | of, or the failure to render, medical care by the hospital |
1477 | covered by the order and its employees and agents shall be up to |
1478 | $500,000 in the aggregate for all related claims or judgments |
1479 | for noneconomic damages arising out of the same incident or |
1480 | occurrence. Claims or judgments for noneconomic damages and |
1481 | awards of past economic damages shall be offset by collateral |
1482 | sources, and paid in full at the time of final settlement. |
1483 | Awards of future economic damages, after being offset by |
1484 | collateral sources, shall be reduced, at the option of the |
1485 | teaching hospital, by the court to present value and paid in |
1486 | full or paid by means of periodic payments in the form of |
1487 | annuities or reversionary trusts, such payments to be paid for |
1488 | the life of the claimant or for so long as the condition for |
1489 | which the award was made persists, whichever is shorter, without |
1490 | regard to the number of years awarded by the trier of fact, at |
1491 | which time the obligation to make such payments terminates. A |
1492 | company that underwrites an annuity to pay future economic |
1493 | damages shall have a Best Company rating of not less than A. The |
1494 | terms of a reversionary instrument used to periodically pay |
1495 | future economic damages must be approved by the court, such |
1496 | approval may not be unreasonably withheld. |
1497 | (4) The limitations on damages in subsection (3) apply |
1498 | prospectively to causes of action for medical negligence that |
1499 | arise on or after the effective date of the order. |
1500 | (5) Upon entry of an order approving the petition, the |
1501 | agency may conduct onsite examinations of the licensed facility |
1502 | to assure continued compliance with terms and conditions of the |
1503 | order. |
1504 | (6) The agency order certifying approval of a petition |
1505 | under this section remains in effect until revoked. The agency |
1506 | may revoke the order upon reasonable notice to the affected |
1507 | hospital that it fails to comply with material requirements of |
1508 | ss. 766.401-766.409 or material conditions of the order |
1509 | certifying compliance with required patient safety measures and |
1510 | that the hospital has failed to cure stated deficiencies upon |
1511 | reasonable notice. Revocation of an agency order certifying |
1512 | approval of an enterprise plan for patient protection and |
1513 | provider liability applies prospectively to causes of action for |
1514 | medical negligence that arise on or after the effective date of |
1515 | the order of revocation. |
1516 | (7) An agency order certifying approval of a petition |
1517 | under this section shall, as a matter of law, constitute |
1518 | conclusive evidence that the hospital complies with all |
1519 | applicable patient safety requirements of s. 766.403. A |
1520 | hospital's noncompliance with the requirements of s. 766.403 may |
1521 | not affect the limitations on damages conferred by this section. |
1522 | Evidence of noncompliance with s. 766.403 may not be admissible |
1523 | for any purpose in any action for medical malpractice. This |
1524 | section, or any portion thereof, may not give rise to an |
1525 | independent cause of action for damages against any hospital. |
1526 | (8) The entry of an agency order pursuant to this section |
1527 | does not impose enterprise liability, or sole and exclusive |
1528 | liability, on the licensed facility for acts or omissions of |
1529 | medical negligence within the premises. |
1530 | (9) An eligible hospital may petition the agency for an |
1531 | order pursuant to this section or an order pursuant to s. |
1532 | 766.404. However, a hospital may not be approved for both |
1533 | enterprise liability under s. 766.404 and the limitations on |
1534 | damages under this section. |
1535 | (10) This section may not apply to hospitals that are |
1536 | subject to sovereign immunity under s. 768.28. |
1537 | Section 18. Section 766.410, Florida Statutes, is created |
1538 | to read: |
1539 | 766.410 Rulemaking authority.--The agency may adopt rules |
1540 | to administer ss. 766.401-766.409. |
1541 | Section 19. Subsections (5) and (12) of section 768.28, |
1542 | Florida Statutes, are amended to read: |
1543 | 768.28 Waiver of sovereign immunity in tort actions; |
1544 | recovery limits; limitation on attorney fees; statute of |
1545 | limitations; exclusions; indemnification; risk management |
1546 | programs.-- |
1547 | (5)(a) The state and its agencies and subdivisions shall |
1548 | be liable for tort claims in the same manner and to the same |
1549 | extent as a private individual under like circumstances, but |
1550 | liability does shall not include punitive damages or interest |
1551 | for the period before judgment. |
1552 | (b) Except as provided in paragraph (c), neither the state |
1553 | or nor its agencies or subdivisions are shall be liable to pay a |
1554 | claim or a judgment by any one person which exceeds the sum of |
1555 | $100,000 or any claim or judgment, or portions thereof, which, |
1556 | when totaled with all other claims or judgments paid by the |
1557 | state or its agencies or subdivisions arising out of the same |
1558 | incident or occurrence, exceeds the sum of $200,000. However, a |
1559 | judgment or judgments may be claimed and rendered in excess of |
1560 | these amounts and may be settled and paid pursuant to this act |
1561 | up to $100,000 or $200,000, as the case may be; and that portion |
1562 | of the judgment that exceeds these amounts may be reported to |
1563 | the Legislature, but may be paid in part or in whole only by |
1564 | further act of the Legislature. Notwithstanding the limited |
1565 | waiver of sovereign immunity provided herein, the state or an |
1566 | agency or subdivision thereof may agree, within the limits of |
1567 | insurance coverage provided, to settle a claim made or a |
1568 | judgment rendered against it without further action by the |
1569 | Legislature, but the state or agency or subdivision thereof |
1570 | shall not be deemed to have waived any defense of sovereign |
1571 | immunity or to have increased the limits of its liability as a |
1572 | result of its obtaining insurance coverage for tortious acts in |
1573 | excess of the $100,000 or $200,000 waiver provided above. The |
1574 | limitations of liability set forth in this subsection shall |
1575 | apply to the state and its agencies and subdivisions whether or |
1576 | not the state or its agencies or subdivisions possessed |
1577 | sovereign immunity before July 1, 1974. |
1578 | (c) In any action for medical negligence within a |
1579 | certified patient safety facility that is covered by sovereign |
1580 | immunity, given that the licensed health care facility bears |
1581 | sole and exclusive liability for acts of medical negligence |
1582 | pursuant to the Enterprise Act for Patient Protection and |
1583 | Provider Liability, inclusive of ss. 766.401-766.409, neither |
1584 | the state or its agencies or subdivisions are liable to pay a |
1585 | claim or a judgment by any one person which exceeds the sum of |
1586 | $150,000 or any claim or judgment, or portions thereof, which, |
1587 | when totaled with all other claims or judgments paid by the |
1588 | state or its agencies or subdivisions arising out of the same |
1589 | incident or occurrence, exceeds the sum of $300,000. However, a |
1590 | judgment may be claimed and rendered in excess of these amounts |
1591 | and may be settled and paid up to $150,000 or $300,000, as the |
1592 | case may be. That portion of the judgment which exceeds these |
1593 | amounts may be reported to the Legislature, but may be paid in |
1594 | part or in whole only by further act of the Legislature. |
1595 | Notwithstanding the limited waiver of sovereign immunity |
1596 | provided in this paragraph, the state or an agency or |
1597 | subdivision thereof may agree, within the limits of insurance |
1598 | coverage provided, to settle a claim made or a judgment rendered |
1599 | against it without further action by the Legislature, but the |
1600 | state or agency or subdivision thereof does not waive any |
1601 | defense of sovereign immunity or increase limits of its |
1602 | liability as a result of its obtaining insurance coverage for |
1603 | tortious acts in excess of the $150,000 waiver or the $300,000 |
1604 | waiver provided in this paragraph. The limitations of liability |
1605 | set forth in this paragraph apply to the state and its agencies |
1606 | and subdivisions whether or not the state or its agencies or |
1607 | subdivisions possessed sovereign immunity before July 1, 1974. |
1608 | (12)(a) A health care practitioner, as defined in s. |
1609 | 456.001(4), who has contractually agreed to act as an agent of a |
1610 | state university board of trustees to provide medical services |
1611 | to a student athlete for participation in or as a result of |
1612 | intercollegiate athletics, to include team practices, training, |
1613 | and competitions, is shall be considered an agent of the |
1614 | respective state university board of trustees, for the purposes |
1615 | of this section, while acting within the scope of and pursuant |
1616 | to guidelines established in that contract. The contracts shall |
1617 | provide for the indemnification of the state by the agent for |
1618 | any liabilities incurred up to the limits set out in this |
1619 | chapter. |
1620 | (b) This subsection shall not be construed as designating |
1621 | persons providing contracted health care services to athletes as |
1622 | employees or agents of a state university board of trustees for |
1623 | the purposes of chapter 440. |
1624 | (c)1. For purposes of this subsection, the terms |
1625 | "certified patient safety facility," "medical staff," and |
1626 | "medical negligence" have the same meanings as provided in s. |
1627 | 766.401. |
1628 | 2. A certified patient safety facility, wherein a minimum |
1629 | of 90 percent of the members of the medical staff consist of |
1630 | physicians are employees or agents of a state university, is an |
1631 | agent of the respective state university board of trustees for |
1632 | purposes of this section to the extent that the licensed |
1633 | facility, in accordance with an enterprise plan for patient |
1634 | protection and provider liability, inclusive of ss. 766.401- |
1635 | 766.409, approved by the Agency for Health Care Administration, |
1636 | is solely and exclusively liable for acts of medical negligence |
1637 | of physicians providing health care services within the licensed |
1638 | facility. |
1639 | 3. A certified patient safety facility that has been found |
1640 | to be an agent of the state for other purposes and has adopted |
1641 | an enterprise plan for patient protection and provider liability |
1642 | for the sole and exclusive liability for acts of medical |
1643 | negligence of affected practitioners who are employees and |
1644 | agents of the affiliated state university board of trustees and |
1645 | its own hospital employees and agents, inclusive of ss. 766.401- |
1646 | 766.409, approved by the Agency for Health Care Administration, |
1647 | is an agent of the respective state university board of trustees |
1648 | for purposes of this subsection only. |
1649 | 4. Subject to the acceptance of the Board of Governors and |
1650 | a state university board of trustees, a licensed facility as |
1651 | described by this subsection may secure the limits of liability |
1652 | protection described in paragraph (c) from a self insurance |
1653 | program created pursuant to s. 1004.24. |
1654 | 5. A notice of intent to commence an action for medical |
1655 | negligence arising from the care or treatment of a patient in a |
1656 | certified patient safety facility subject to the provisions of |
1657 | this subsection shall be sent to the licensed facility as the |
1658 | statutory agent created pursuant to an enterprise plan of the |
1659 | related board of trustees of a state university for the limited |
1660 | purposes of administering an enterprise plan for patient |
1661 | protection and provider liability. A complaint alleging medical |
1662 | negligence resulting in damages to a patient in a certified |
1663 | patient safety facility subject to the provisions of this |
1664 | paragraph shall be commenced against the applicable board of |
1665 | trustees of a state university on the relation of the licensed |
1666 | facility, and the doctrines of res judicata and collateral |
1667 | estoppel shall apply. The complaint shall be served on the |
1668 | licensed facility. Any notice of intent mailed to the licensed |
1669 | facility, any legal process served on the licensed facility, and |
1670 | any other notice, paper, or pleading that is served, sent, or |
1671 | delivered to the licensed facility pertaining to a claim of |
1672 | medical negligence shall have the same legal force and effect as |
1673 | mailing, service, or delivery to a duly authorized agent of the |
1674 | board of trustees of the respective state university, |
1675 | notwithstanding any provision of the laws of this state to the |
1676 | contrary. Upon receipt of any such notice of intent, complaint |
1677 | for damages, or other notice, paper, or pleading pertaining to a |
1678 | claim of medical negligence, a licensed facility subject to the |
1679 | provisions of this paragraph shall give timely notice to the |
1680 | related board of trustees of the state university, although |
1681 | failure to give timely notice does not affect the legal |
1682 | sufficiency of the notice of intent, service of process, or |
1683 | other notice, paper, or pleading. A final judgment or binding |
1684 | arbitration award against the board of trustees of a state |
1685 | university on the relation of a licensed facility, arising from |
1686 | a claim of medical negligence resulting in damages to a patient |
1687 | in a certified patient safety facility subject to the provisions |
1688 | of this paragraph, may be enforced in the same manner, and is |
1689 | subject to the same limitations on enforcement or recovery, as |
1690 | any final judgment for damages or binding arbitration award |
1691 | against the board of trustees of a state university, |
1692 | notwithstanding any provision of the laws of this state to the |
1693 | contrary. Any settlement agreement executed by the board of |
1694 | trustees of a state university on the relation of a licensed |
1695 | facility, arising from a claim of medical negligence resulting |
1696 | in damages to a patient in a certified patient safety facility |
1697 | subject to the provisions of this paragraph, may be enforced in |
1698 | the same manner and is subject to the same limitations as a |
1699 | settlement agreement executed by an authorized agent of the |
1700 | board of trustees. The board of trustees of a state university |
1701 | may make payment to a claimant in whole or in part of any |
1702 | portion of a final judgment or binding arbitration award against |
1703 | the board of trustees of a state university on the relation of a |
1704 | licensed facility, and any portion of a settlement of a claim |
1705 | for medical negligence arising from a certified patient safety |
1706 | facility subject to the provisions of this paragraph, which |
1707 | exceeds the amounts of the limited waiver of sovereign immunity |
1708 | specified in paragraph (5)(c), only as provided in that |
1709 | paragraph. |
1710 | Section 20. If any provision of this act or its |
1711 | application to any person or circumstance is held invalid, the |
1712 | invalidity does not affect other provisions or applications of |
1713 | the act which can be given effect without the invalid provision |
1714 | or application, and to this end, the provisions of this act are |
1715 | severable. |
1716 | Section 21. If a conflict between any provision of this |
1717 | act and s. 456.052, s. 456.053, s. 456.054, s. 458.331, s. |
1718 | 459.015, or s. 817.505, Florida Statutes, the provisions of this |
1719 | act shall govern. The provisions of this act should be broadly |
1720 | construed in furtherance of the overriding legislative intent to |
1721 | facilitate innovative approaches for patient protection and |
1722 | provider liability in eligible hospitals. |
1723 | Section 22. It is the intention of the Legislature that |
1724 | the provisions of this act are self-executing. |
1725 | Section 23. This act shall take effect upon becoming a |
1726 | law. |