1

A bill to be entitled

2

An act relating to beach management; amending s. 161.142,

3

F.S.; providing legislative intent and findings; providing

4

requirements concerning the quality and quantity of

5

dredged sand placed on certain beaches adjacent to inlets;

6

requiring an estimation of the requisite quantity of

7

beach-quality sand by the Department of Environmental

8

Protection and its consultants; requiring the protection

9

of shorebirds and marine turtles; applying requirements

10

concerning the placement of dredged sand on adjacent

11

beaches to the inlet management projects of certain ports;

12

providing an exemption from such requirements; providing

13

that the inlet projects of such ports are eligible for

14

funding; providing requirements and findings concerning

15

the placement of dredged sand from federal navigation

16

projects; providing for assignment of responsibility for

17

the erosion caused by inlets; specifying actions to be

18

taken by the department in disputes between local

19

governments and property owners concerning how much sand

20

should bypass an inlet; creating s. 161.143, F.S.;

21

requiring that inlet management studies, projects, and

22

activities be supported by certain plans; providing

23

criteria governing the department's ranking of inlet

24

management projects and activities; specifying conditions

25

that must be met; requiring that the department establish

26

funding priorities for projects and activities concerning

27

inlet management; providing for input from interested

28

governmental and private entities; providing criteria for

29

establishing priorities; authorizing funding levels for

30

inlet management projects under specified conditions;

31

requiring that the department annually provide an inlet

32

management project list to the Legislature; providing

33

requirements for the list; requiring that the department

34

make available certain moneys for projects on the list;

35

requiring that the department make available certain

36

moneys for projects on the list which are legislatively

37

approved; requiring that the Legislature designate certain

38

inlet projects as "Inlet of the Year"; requiring the

39

department to provide an annual report to the Legislature

40

concerning the success of projects so designated;

41

authorizing rulemaking by the department; providing an

42

effective date.

43

44

Be It Enacted by the Legislature of the State of Florida:

45

46

     Section 1.  Section 161.142, Florida Statutes, is amended to

47

read:

48

     161.142  Declaration of public policy relating to improved

49

navigation inlets.--The Legislature hereby recognizes the need

50

for maintaining navigation inlets to promote commercial and

51

recreational uses of our coastal waters and their resources. The

52

Legislature further recognizes that inlets interrupt or alter the

53

natural drift of beach-quality sand resources, which often

54

results in these sand resources being deposited in nearshore

55

around shallow outer-bar areas or in the inlet channel, instead

56

of providing natural nourishment to the adjacent eroding

57

downdrift beaches. Accordingly, the Legislature finds it is in

58

the public interest to replicate the natural drift of sand which

59

is interrupted or altered by inlets to be replaced and for each

60

level of government to undertake all reasonable efforts to

61

maximize inlet sand bypassing to ensure that beach-quality sand

62

is placed on adjacent eroding beaches. Such activities cannot

63

make up for the historical sand deficits caused by inlets, but

64

shall be designed to balance the sediment budget of the inlet and

65

adjacent beaches and extend the life of proximate beach-

66

restoration projects so that periodic nourishment is needed less

67

frequently. Therefore, in furtherance of this declaration of

68

public policy, and the Legislature's intent to redirect and

69

recommit the state's comprehensive beach management efforts to

70

address the beach erosion caused by inlets, the department shall

71

ensure that:

72

     (1)  All construction and maintenance dredgings of beach-

73

quality sand are should be placed on the adjacent eroding

74

downdrift beaches unless; or, if placed elsewhere, an equivalent

75

quality and quantity of sand from an alternate location is should

76

be placed on the adjacent eroding downdrift beaches.

77

     (2) On an average annual basis, a quantity of beach-quality

78

sand is should be placed on the adjacent eroding downdrift

79

beaches which is equal to the natural net annual longshore

80

sediment transport. The department shall, with the assistance of

81

university-based or other contractual resources that it may

82

employ or call upon, maintain a current estimate of such

83

quantities of sand for purposes of prioritizing, planning, and

84

permitting.

85

     (3) Construction waterward of the coastal construction

86

control line on downdrift coastal areas, on islands substantially

87

created by the deposit of spoil, located within 1 mile of the

88

centerline of navigation channels or inlets, providing access to

89

ports listed in s. 403.021(9)(b), which suffers or has suffered

90

erosion caused by such navigation channel maintenance or

91

construction shall be exempt from the permitting requirements and

92

prohibitions of subsections (2), (5), and (6) of s. 161.053. The

93

timing and sequence of any construction activities associated

94

with inlet management projects in such coastal areas shall comply

95

with 44 C.F.R. part 60 and shall provide protection to nesting

96

sea turtles and their hatchlings and their habitats, to nesting

97

shorebirds, and to native salt-resistant vegetation and

98

endangered plant communities. Beach-quality sand placed on the

99

beach as part of an inlet management project must be suitable for

100

marine turtle nesting.

101

     (4) The provisions of subsections (1) and (2) are shall not

102

be a requirement imposed upon ports listed in s. 403.021(9)(b).

103

However, such ports must demonstrate reasonable efforts to place

104

beach-quality sand from construction and maintenance dredging and

105

port-development projects on adjacent eroding beaches in

106

accordance with port master plans approved by the Department of

107

Community Affairs and with permits approved and issued by the

108

Department of Environmental Protection in order to ensure

109

compliance with this section. A port may sponsor or cosponsor

110

inlet management projects that are fully eligible for state cost

111

sharing.

112

     (5) The department shall ensure that the disposal of beach-

113

quality sand from federal projects in this state which involve

114

dredging for the purpose of navigation is placed on, or in the

115

nearshore area of, adjacent eroding beaches. The department may

116

consider permitting nearshore or upland disposal of such beach-

117

quality sand if emergency conditions exist. The state recognizes

118

that due to the growing demand for beach-quality sand resources

119

for beach restoration and nourishment projects, the limited

120

supply of such sand resources, and the cost of such projects,

121

beach or nearshore sand placement is the least-cost disposal

122

method.

123

     (6) If federal investigations and reports or state-approved

124

inlet management plans do not specify the entity or entities

125

responsible for the extent of erosion caused by an inlet, the

126

department or local government, with the assistance of

127

university-based or other contractual resources that they may

128

employ or call upon, is encouraged to undertake assessments that

129

aid in specifying the responsible entity or entities and in more

130

accurately determining cost-sharing responsibilities for measures

131

to correct such erosion. The entity that is responsible for

132

maintenance dredging of an inlet may be deemed responsible for

133

the erosion caused by the inlet if another responsible party is

134

not specified in such an assessment, a shore-protection project

135

investigation or report, or a state-approved inlet management

136

plan.

137

     (7) If the beneficiaries of the inlet, the local

138

governments having jurisdiction of lands adjacent to the inlet,

139

or the owners of property adjacent to the inlet, are involved in

140

a dispute concerning how much sand should be bypassed, the

141

department shall protect its monetary investment in beach

142

nourishment projects within the inlet's physical zone of

143

influence by taking all reasonable actions to balance the

144

sediment budget of the inlet and adjacent beaches, including

145

implementation of inlet sand bypassing and other inlet management

146

projects.

147

     Section 2.  Section 161.143, Florida Statutes, is created to

148

read:

149

     161.143 Inlet management; planning, prioritizing, funding,

150

approving, and implementing projects.--

151

     (1) Studies, projects, and activities for the purpose of

152

mitigating the erosive effects of inlets and balancing the

153

sediment budget of the inlet and adjacent beaches must be

154

supported by separately approved inlet management plans or inlet

155

components of the statewide comprehensive beach management plan.

156

Such plans in support of individual inlet projects or activities

157

must, pursuant to s. 161.161(1)(b), evaluate each inlet to

158

determine the extent of the inlet's erosive effect on adjacent

159

beaches, and if significant, make recommendations to mitigate

160

such ongoing erosive effects and provide estimated costs for such

161

mitigation.

162

     (2) The department shall establish annual funding

163

priorities for studies, activities, or other projects concerning

164

inlet management. Such inlet management projects include, but are

165

not limited to, inlet sand bypassing, modifications to channel

166

dredging, jetty redesign, jetty repair, disposal of spoil

167

material, and the development, revision, adoption, or

168

implementation of an inlet management plan. The funding

169

priorities established by the department must be consistent with

170

the requirements and legislative declaration in ss. 161.101(14),

171

161.142, and 161.161(1)(b). In establishing funding priorities

172

under this subsection and before transmitting the annual inlet

173

project list to the Legislature under subsection (5), the

174

department shall seek formal input from local coastal

175

governments, beach and general government associations and other

176

coastal interest groups, and university experts concerning annual

177

funding priorities for inlet management projects. In order to

178

maximize the benefits of efforts to address the inlet-caused

179

beach erosion problems of this state, the ranking criteria used

180

by the department to establish funding priorities for studies,

181

activities, or other projects concerning inlet management must

182

include consideration of:

183

     (a) An estimate of the annual quantity of beach-quality

184

sand reaching the updrift boundary of the improved jetty or inlet

185

channel.

186

     (b) The severity of the erosion to the adjacent beaches

187

caused by the inlet, and the extent to which the proposed project

188

mitigates the erosive effects of the inlet.

189

     (c) The overall significance and anticipated success of the

190

proposed project in balancing the sediment budget of the inlet

191

and adjacent beaches and addressing the sand deficit along the

192

inlet-affected shorelines.

193

     (d) The extent to which existing bypassing activities at an

194

inlet would benefit from modest, cost-effective improvements when

195

considering the volumetric increases from the proposed project,

196

the availability of beach-quality sand currently not being

197

bypassed to adjacent eroding beaches, and the ease with which

198

such beach-quality sand may be obtained.

199

     (e) The interest and commitment of local governments as

200

demonstrated by their willingness to coordinate the planning,

201

design, construction, and maintenance of an inlet management

202

project and their financial plan for funding the local cost-share

203

for initial construction, ongoing sand bypassing, channel

204

dredging, and maintenance.

205

     (f) The previous completion or approval of a state-

206

sponsored inlet management plan or local-government-sponsored

207

inlet study concerning the inlet addressed by the proposed

208

project, the ease of updating and revising any such plan or

209

study, and the adequacy and specificity of the plan's or study's

210

recommendations concerning the mitigation of an inlet's erosive

211

effects on adjacent beaches.

212

     (g) The degree to which the proposed project will enhance

213

the performance and longevity of proximate beach nourishment

214

projects, thereby reducing the frequency of such periodic

215

nourishment projects.

216

     (h) The project-ranking criteria in s. 161.101(14) to the

217

extent such criteria are applicable to inlet management studies,

218

projects, and activities.

219

     (3) The department may, pursuant to s. 161.101 and

220

notwithstanding s. 161.101(15), pay from legislative

221

appropriations provided for these purposes 75 percent of the

222

total costs or, if applicable, the nonfederal costs, of a study,

223

activity, or other project concerning the management of an inlet.

224

The balance must be paid by the local governments or special

225

districts having jurisdiction over the property where the inlet

226

is located.

227

     (4) Using the legislative appropriation to the statewide

228

beach-management-support category of the department's fixed

229

capital outlay funding request, the department may employ

230

university-based or other contractual sources and pay 100 percent

231

of the costs of studies that are consistent with the legislative

232

declaration in s. 161.142 and that:

233

     (a) Determine, calculate, refine, and achieve general

234

consensus regarding net annual sediment transport volumes to be

235

used for the purpose of planning and prioritizing inlet

236

management projects; and

237

     (b) Appropriate, assign, and apportion responsibilities

238

between inlet beneficiaries for the erosion caused by a

239

particular inlet on adjacent beaches.

240

     (5) The department shall annually provide an inlet

241

management project list, in priority order, to the Legislature as

242

part of the department's budget request. The list must include

243

studies, projects, or other activities that address the

244

management of at least 10 separate inlets and that are ranked

245

according to the criteria established under subsection (2).

246

     (a) The department shall make available at least 10 percent

247

of the total amount that the Legislature appropriates in each

248

fiscal year for statewide beach management for the three highest-

249

ranked projects on the current year's inlet management project

250

list.

251

     (b) The department shall make available at least 50 percent

252

of the funds appropriated for the feasibility and design category

253

in the department's fixed capital outlay funding request for

254

projects on the current year's inlet management project list

255

which involve the study for, or design or development of, an

256

inlet management project.

257

     (c) The department shall make available all statewide beach

258

management funds that remain unencumbered or are allocated to

259

non-project-specific activities for projects on legislatively

260

approved inlet management project lists. Funding for local-

261

government-specific projects on annual project lists approved by

262

the Legislature must remain available for such purposes for a

263

period of 18 months, pursuant to s. 216.301(2)(a). Based on an

264

assessment and the department's determination that a project will

265

not be ready to proceed during this 18-month period, such funds

266

shall be used for inlet management projects on legislatively

267

approved lists.

268

     (d) The Legislature shall designate one of the three

269

highest projects on the inlet management project list in any year

270

as the Inlet of the Year. The department shall annually report to

271

the Legislature concerning the extent to which each inlet project

272

designated by the Legislature as Inlet of the Year has succeeded

273

in balancing the sediment budget of the inlet and adjacent

274

beaches, mitigating the inlet's erosive effects on adjacent

275

beaches, and transferring or otherwise placing beach-quality sand

276

on adjacent eroding beaches.

277

     (6) The department shall adopt rules under ss. 120.536(1)

278

and 120.54 to administer this section.

279

     Section 3.  This act shall take effect July 1, 2008.