1

The Committee on Criminal Justice (Dockery) recommended the

2

following amendment:

3

4

     Senate Amendment (with title amendment)

5

     Delete everything after the enacting clause

6

and insert:

7

     Section 1.  Section 921.0019, Florida Statutes, is created

8

to read:

9

921.0019 Sentencing Policy Advisory Council.--

10

     (1) The Sentencing Policy Advisory Council is created

11

within the Legislature for the purpose of evaluating sentencing

12

policy, sentencing practices, and laws affecting or applicable

13

to sentencing or punishment, including, but not limited to, the

14

Criminal Punishment Code, the degree and offense severity level

15

ranking of offenses, mandatory sentences, enhanced penalties,

16

felony and misdemeanor reclassifications, gain-time and early

17

release mechanisms, and for the purpose of making findings and

18

recommendations on a continuing basis regarding changes to such

19

policy, practices, and laws. The council shall serve in an

20

advisory capacity to the Legislature, the Governor, and the

21

Supreme Court.

22

     (2) Any recommended change to sentencing policy,

23

sentencing practices, or laws affecting or applicable to

24

sentencing or punishment must be consistent with the following

25

goals:

26

     (a) Protecting public safety, including, but not limited

27

to, ensuring the incarceration of violent criminal offenders and

28

nonviolent criminal offenders who commit repeated acts of

29

criminal behavior and who have demonstrated an inability to

30

comply with less restrictive penalties previously imposed for

31

nonviolent criminal acts;

32

     (b) Supporting the principles embodied in the Criminal

33

Punishment Code as described in s. 921.002(1); and

34

     (c) Providing for the most cost-effective and efficient

35

use of correctional resources to the extent that such use is not

36

in conflict with the goals described in paragraphs (a) and (b).

37

     (3)(a) The council shall be composed of 15 members,

38

consisting of: two members of the Senate appointed by the

39

President of the Senate; two members of the House of

40

Representatives appointed by the Speaker of the House of

41

Representatives; the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court or a

42

member of the Supreme Court designated by the Chief Justice;

43

three circuit court judges, one county court judge, and one

44

representative of the victim advocacy profession, appointed by

45

the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court; the Attorney General or

46

her or his designee; and the Secretary of the Department of

47

Corrections or her or his designee. The following members shall

48

be appointed by the Governor: one state attorney from a list of

49

three nominees recommended by the Florida Prosecuting Attorneys

50

Association; one public defender from a list of three nominees

51

recommended by the Public Defenders Association; and one private

52

attorney from a list of three nominees recommended by the

53

President of The Florida Bar. The membership of the council

54

shall reflect the geographic and ethnic diversity of the state.

55

The chair of the council shall be selected by the members for a

56

term of 1 year.

57

     (b) The members of the council shall be appointed to serve

58

4-year terms, except that a legislative member's term expires

59

upon leaving office as a member of the Senate or the House of

60

Representatives.

61

     (c) The council shall meet at least quarterly and other

62

meetings may be called by the chair upon giving 7 days' notice

63

to the public. The council may take public testimony.

64

     (d) Members of the council shall serve without

65

compensation, but are entitled to reimbursement for per diem and

66

travel expenses, which shall be paid by the appointing entity.

67

     (e) The Office of Legislative Services shall provide staff

68

support for the council. The council staff members shall consist

69

of an executive director and any other staff member determined

70

to be necessary to the completion of the council's duties,

71

subject to appropriations. Upon request of the chair of the

72

council or the executive director, the Legislature's Office of

73

Economic and Demographic Research, the Office of Program Policy

74

Analysis and Government Accountability, the Department of

75

Corrections and any other state agency or department, and the

76

Office of the State Courts Administrator shall assist the

77

council in providing necessary data collection, analysis, and

78

research.

79

     (4) On or before January 15 of each year, the council

80

shall provide a report of its findings and recommendations to

81

the Governor, the President of the Senate, the Speaker of the

82

House of Representatives, and the Chief Justice of the Supreme

83

Court. The council may provide the Legislature, the Governor,

84

and the Supreme Court with additional reports of findings and

85

recommendations at any time it deems appropriate.

86

     (5) The President of the Senate or the Speaker of the

87

House may also direct the council to report by a certain date

88

the council's findings and recommendations regarding an issue

89

pertinent to sentencing policy, sentencing practice, or laws

90

affecting or applicable to sentencing or punishment.

91

     Section 2. (1) On or before January 15, 2009, the

92

Sentencing Policy Advisory Council shall report to the Governor,

93

the President of the Senate, the Speaker of the House of

94

Representatives, and the Supreme Court its preliminary findings

95

and recommendations regarding the following questions:

96

     (a) Should the Legislature repeal any laws providing for a

97

mandatory minimum sentence or modify such laws to provide for

98

presumptive mandatory minimum sentences or exceptions to

99

mandatory sentences in some circumstances?

100

     (b) Do mandatory sentencing laws conflict with or

101

undermine the purpose of the Criminal Punishment Code?

102

     (c) Are particular criminal acts punished as more than one

103

specific offense and, if so, has this resulted in duplication,

104

confusion, or inconsistent penalties?

105

     (d) Are the penalties for particular felony or misdemeanor

106

offenses disproportionate to those for other felonies or

107

misdemeanor offenses of a similar nature or severity?

108

     (e) Do current enhanced penalties or felony and

109

misdemeanor reclassifications for repeat offenders result in

110

duplication, confusion, or inconsistent penalties?

111

     (f) Should the Legislature preclude the courts from

112

sentencing to prison defendants convicted of third-degree

113

felonies who score under 44 total sentence points?

114

     (g) Should the Legislature change the current "Truth in

115

Sentencing" gain-time restrictions specified in s.

116

944.275(4)(b)3., Florida Statutes, to more closely align with

117

the federal minimum requirements?

118

     (h) Should the Legislature authorize correctional

119

probation officers to apply a continuum of administrative

120

sanctions for technical probation violations that do not affect

121

public safety?

122

     (2) Findings and recommendations regarding the questions

123

described in subsection (1) are in addition to any findings and

124

recommendations the council is required to provide under s.

125

921.0019, Florida Statutes.

126

     Section 3.  This act shall take effect July 1, 2008.

127

128

================ T I T L E  A M E N D M E N T ================

129

And the title is amended as follows:

130

     Delete everything before the enacting clause

131

and insert:

132

A bill to be entitled

133

An act relating to sentencing; creating s. 921.0019, F.S.;

134

creating the Sentencing Policy Advisory Council within the

135

Legislature; requiring the council to evaluate sentencing

136

policy, sentencing practices, and laws affecting or

137

applicable to sentencing or punishment; requiring that

138

recommendations be consistent with specified goals;

139

providing membership of the council; providing for

140

selection of the chair of the council; providing for an

141

executive director and additional staff for the council,

142

subject to appropriations; providing that members of the

143

council serve without compensation, but are entitled to be

144

reimbursed for per diem and travel expenses; requiring

145

meetings and reports of findings and recommendations to

146

the Governor, the Legislature, and the Florida Supreme

147

Court; requiring the council to report its findings and

148

recommendations regarding specified questions by a

149

specified date; providing an effective date.

3/10/2008  9:33:00 AM     CJ.CJ.04419