Florida Senate - 2008 SB 2568

By Senator Gaetz

4-03538A-08 20082568__

1

A bill to be entitled

2

An act relating to appellate procedure; creating s.

3

59.075, F.S.; providing a right of appeal from an order

4

denying a motion for summary judgment; providing for

5

simultaneous jurisdiction by the trial and appellate

6

courts; requiring the trial court to issue a written order

7

when denying a motion for summary judgment; requesting the

8

Supreme Court to adopt rules; providing an effective date.

9

10

Be It Enacted by the Legislature of the State of Florida:

11

12

     Section 1.  Section 59.075, Florida Statutes, is created to

13

read:

14

     Section 59.075, Florida Statutes, is created to read:

15

     59.075 Appeal from denial of summary judgment.--Upon

16

application made within the time and in the manner provided by

17

the Florida Rules of Appellate Procedure, a party may appeal an

18

order of a trial court in a civil action which denies a motion

19

for summary judgment if the motion was made upon proper notice.

20

     (1) The trial court and the appellate court shall maintain

21

simultaneous jurisdiction over the matter until the appellate

22

court issues an order to show cause to appellee, at which time

23

the trial court shall lose jurisdiction pending disposition of

24

the appeal.

25

     (2) The trial court shall issue a written order denying a

26

motion for summary judgment which states with specificity the

27

legal basis for the denial and enumerates the specific disputed

28

facts deemed material to the trial court.

29

     Section 2. The Legislature requests that the Supreme Court

30

adopt rules providing:

31

     (1) For the submission of evidence into the record of the

32

trial court in support of or opposition to the motion for summary

33

judgment;

34

     (2) For the matter to be transmitted to the appellate court

35

solely on the basis of the summary judgment motion;

36

     (3) For the appellant to submit a brief in support of the

37

appeal which addresses matters overlooked or misapplied by the

38

trial court but does not reargue matters discussed in the trial

39

court order; and

40

     (4) For the party opposing the appeal not to submit a

41

responsive brief until the appellate court enters an order to

42

show cause after determining that the appeal presents a prima

43

facie case for relief.

44

     Section 3.  This act shall take effect July 1, 2008, and

45

applies to any order denying summary judgment which is entered on

46

or after that date.

CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.