1

The Committee on Health and Human Services Appropriations (Gaetz)

2

recommended the following amendment:

3

4

     Senate Amendment (with title amendment)

5

     Delete everything after the enacting clause

6

and insert:

7

     Section 1.  Section 393.12, Florida Statutes, is amended to

8

read:

9

     393.12  Capacity; appointment of guardian advocate.--

10

     (1)  CAPACITY.--

11

     (a) The issue of capacity shall be separate and distinct

12

from a determination of the appropriateness of admission to

13

nonresidential services or residential care for a condition of

14

developmental disabilities. A No person with a developmental

15

disability may not shall be presumed incapacitated solely by

16

reason of his or her acceptance in nonresidential services or

17

admission to residential care and may not; nor shall any such

18

person be denied the full exercise of all legal rights guaranteed

19

to citizens of this state and of the United States.

20

     (b) The determination of incapacity issue of capacity of a

21

person with a developmental disability and the appointment of a

22

guardian must be conducted disabilities shall be determined in a

23

separate proceeding according to the procedures and requirements

24

of chapter 744 and the Florida Probate Rules.

25

     (2)  APPOINTMENT OF A GUARDIAN ADVOCATE.--

26

     (a) Conditions.--A circuit probate court may appoint a

27

guardian advocate, without an adjudication of incapacity, for a

28

person with developmental disabilities, if the person lacks the

29

decisionmaking ability capacity to do some, but not all, of the

30

decisionmaking tasks necessary to care for his or her person or,

31

property, or estate or if the person has voluntarily petitioned

32

for the appointment of a guardian advocate. Except as otherwise

33

specified, the proceeding shall be governed by the Florida Rules

34

of Probate Civil Procedure.

35

     (b) A person who is being considered for appointment or is

36

appointed as a guardian advocate need not be represented by an

37

attorney unless required by the court or if the guardian advocate

38

is delegated any rights regarding property other than the right

39

to be the representative payee for government benefits. This

40

paragraph applies only to proceedings relating to the appointment

41

of a guardian advocate and the court's supervision of a guardian

42

advocate and is not an exercise of the Legislature's authority

43

pursuant to s. (2)(a), Art. V of the State Constitution.

44

     (3)(b) PETITION.--A petition to appoint a guardian advocate

45

for a person with a developmental disability may be executed by

46

an adult person who is a resident of this state. The petition

47

must shall be verified and must shall:

48

     (a)1. State the name, age, and present address of the

49

petitioner and his or her relationship to the person with a

50

developmental disability disabilities;

51

     (b)2. State the name, age, county of residence, and present

52

address of the person with a developmental disability

53

disabilities;

54

     (c)3. Allege that the petitioner believes that the person

55

needs a guardian advocate and specify the factual information on

56

which such belief is based;

57

     (d)4. Specify the exact areas in which the person lacks the

58

decisionmaking ability capacity to make informed decisions about

59

his or her care and treatment services or to meet the essential

60

requirements for his or her physical health or safety;

61

     (e)5. Specify the legal disabilities to which the person is

62

subject; and

63

     (f)6. State the name of the proposed guardian advocate, the

64

relationship of that person to the person with a developmental

65

disability; the relationship that the proposed guardian advocate

66

had or has with a provider of health care services, residential

67

services, or other services to the person with a developmental

68

disability; disabilities, and the reason why this person should

69

be appointed. If a willing and qualified guardian advocate cannot

70

be located, the petition shall so state.

71

     (4)(c) NOTICE.--

72

     (a)1. Notice of the filing of the petition must shall be

73

given to the person with a developmental disability, individual

74

and his or her parent or parents. The notice shall be given both

75

verbally and in writing in the language of the person and in

76

English. Notice must shall also be given to the next of kin of

77

the person with a developmental disability as defined in chapter

78

744, a health care surrogate designated to execute an advance

79

directive under chapter 765, an agent under a durable power of

80

attorney, and such other persons as the court may direct. A copy

81

of the petition to appoint a guardian advocate must shall be

82

served with the notice.

83

     (b)2. The notice must shall state that a hearing will be

84

held shall be set to inquire into the capacity of the person with

85

a developmental disability disabilities to exercise the rights

86

enumerated in the petition. The notice must shall also state the

87

date of the hearing on the petition.

88

     (c)3. The notice shall state that the person with a

89

developmental disability individual with developmental

90

disabilities has the right to be represented by counsel of his or

91

her own choice and that if the person individual cannot afford an

92

attorney, the court shall appoint one.

93

     (5)(d) COUNSEL.--Within 3 days after a petition has been

94

filed, the court shall appoint an attorney to represent a person

95

with a developmental disability who is the subject of a petition

96

to appoint a guardian advocate. The person with a developmental

97

disability may substitute his or her own attorney for the

98

attorney appointed by the court.

99

     (a) If the court appoints the attorney:

100

     1. The court shall appoint a private attorney who shall be

101

selected from the attorney registry compiled pursuant to s.

102

27.40.

103

     2. The attorney must have completed a minimum of 8 hours of

104

education in guardianship. The court may waive this requirement

105

for an attorney who has served as a court-appointed attorney in

106

guardian advocate proceedings or as an attorney of record for

107

guardian advocates for at least 3 years.

108

     (b) An attorney representing a person with a developmental

109

disability may not also serve as the guardian advocate of the

110

person, as counsel for the guardian advocate, or as counsel for

111

the person petitioning for the appointment of a guardian

112

advocate.

113

     1. Every person with developmental disabilities who is the

114

subject of a petition to appoint a guardian advocate shall be

115

represented by counsel.

116

     2. Every person with developmental disabilities has the

117

right to be represented by counsel of his or her own choice. If

118

the person cannot afford an attorney, the court shall appoint one

119

to represent the person. The court shall appoint counsel if no

120

appearance has been filed within 10 working days of the hearing.

121

     (6)(e) HEARING.--

122

     (a)1. Upon the filing of the petition to appoint a guardian

123

advocate, the court shall set a date for holding a hearing on

124

upon which the petition shall be heard. The A hearing must on the

125

petition shall be held as soon as practicable after the petition

126

is filed, but reasonable delay for the purpose of investigation,

127

discovery, or procuring counsel or witnesses may shall be

128

granted.

129

     (b)2. The hearing must be held shall be conducted at the

130

time and place specified in the notice of hearing and must. The

131

hearing shall be conducted in a manner consistent with due

132

process.

133

     (c)3. The person with a developmental disability individual

134

has the right to be present at the hearing and shall be present

135

unless good cause to exclude the individual can be shown. The

136

person individual has the right to remain silent, to present

137

evidence, to call and cross-examine witnesses, and to have the

138

hearing open or closed, as the person may choose.

139

     (d)4. At the hearing, the court shall receive and consider

140

all reports relevant to the person's disability disabilities,

141

including, but not limited to, the person's current individual

142

family or individual support plan, the individual education plan,

143

and other professional reports documenting the condition and

144

needs of the person individual.

145

     (e)5. The Florida Evidence Code, chapter 90, applies shall

146

apply at the hearing. The burden of proof must shall be by clear

147

and convincing evidence.

148

     (7) ADVANCE DIRECTIVES FOR HEALTH CARE AND DURABLE POWER OF

149

ATTORNEY.--In each proceeding in which a guardian advocate is

150

appointed under this section, the court shall determine whether

151

the person with a developmental disability has executed any valid

152

advance directive under chapter 765 or a durable power of

153

attorney under chapter 709.

154

     (a) If the person with a developmental disability has

155

executed an advance directive or durable power of attorney, the

156

court must consider and find whether the documents will

157

sufficiently address the needs of the person with a developmental

158

disability for whom the guardian advocate is sought. A guardian

159

advocate may not be appointed if the court finds that the advance

160

directive or durable power of attorney provides an alternative to

161

the appointment of a guardian advocate which will sufficiently

162

address the needs of the person with a developmental disability.

163

     (b) If an interested person seeks to contest an advance

164

directive or durable power of attorney executed by a person with

165

a developmental disability, the interested person shall file a

166

verified statement. The verified statement shall include the

167

factual basis for the belief that the advance directive or

168

durable power of attorney is invalid or does not sufficiently

169

address the needs of the person for whom a guardian advocate is

170

sought or that the person with authority under the advance

171

directive or durable power of attorney is abusing his or her

172

power.

173

     (c) If an advance directive exists, the court shall specify

174

in its order and letters of guardian advocacy what authority, if

175

any, the guardian advocate shall exercise over the person's

176

health care surrogate. Pursuant to the grounds listed in s.

177

765.105, the court, upon its own motion, may, with notice to the

178

health care surrogate and any other appropriate parties, modify

179

or revoke the authority of the health care surrogate to make

180

health care decisions for the person with a developmental

181

disability. For purposes of this section, the term "health care

182

decision" has the same meaning as in s. 765.101.

183

     (d) If any durable power of attorney exists, the court

184

shall specify in its order and letters of guardian advocacy what

185

powers of the agent, if any, are suspended and granted to the

186

guardian advocate. The court, however, may not suspend any powers

187

of the agent unless the court determines the durable power of

188

attorney is invalid or there is an abuse by the agent of the

189

powers granted.

190

     (8)(f) COURT ORDER determining the appointment of a

191

guardian advocate.--If the court finds the person with a

192

developmental disability disabilities requires the appointment of

193

a guardian advocate, the court shall enter a written order

194

appointing the guardian advocate and containing determining the

195

need for a guardian advocate. The written order shall contain the

196

findings of facts and conclusions of law on which the court made

197

its decision, including. The court shall make the following

198

findings:

199

     (a)1. The nature and scope of the person's lack of

200

decisionmaking ability incapacity;

201

     (b)2. The exact areas in which the individual lacks

202

decisionmaking ability capacity to make informed decisions about

203

care and treatment services or to meet the essential requirements

204

for his or her physical health and safety;

205

     (c)3. The specific legal disabilities to which the person

206

with developmental disability disabilities is subject; and

207

     (d) The name of the person selected as guardian advocate

208

and the reasons for the court's selection; and

209

     (e)4. The powers, and duties, and responsibilities of the

210

guardian advocate, including bonding of the guardian advocate, as

211

provided in governed by s. 744.351.

212

     (9)(g) LEGAL RIGHTS.--A person with a developmental

213

disability disabilities for whom a guardian advocate has been

214

appointed retains all legal rights except those that which have

215

been specifically granted to the guardian advocate.

216

     (10)(h) POWERS AND DUTIES OF GUARDIAN ADVOCATE.--A guardian

217

advocate for a person with a developmental disability

218

disabilities shall be a person or corporation qualified to act as

219

guardian, with the same powers, duties, and responsibilities

220

required of a guardian under chapter 744 or those defined by

221

court order under this section. However, a guardian advocate may

222

not be required to file an annual accounting under s. 744.3678 if

223

the court determines that the person with a developmental

224

disability disabilities receives income only from Social Security

225

benefits and the guardian advocate is the person's representative

226

payee for the benefits.

227

     (11)(3) COURT COSTS.--In all proceedings under this

228

section, no court costs may not shall be charged against the

229

agency.

230

     (12) SUGGESTION OF RESTORATION OF RIGHTS.--Any interested

231

person, including the person with a developmental disability, may

232

file a suggestion of restoration of rights with the court in

233

which the guardian advocacy is pending. The suggestion must state

234

that the person with a developmental disability is currently

235

capable of exercising some or all of the rights that were

236

delegated to the guardian advocate and provide evidentiary

237

support for the filing of the suggestion. Evidentiary support

238

includes, but is not limited to, a signed statement from a

239

medical, psychological, or psychiatric practitioner by whom the

240

person with a developmental disability was evaluated and which

241

supports the suggestion for the restoration. If the petitioner is

242

unable to provide evidentiary support due to the lack of access

243

to such information or reports, the petitioner may state a good

244

faith basis for the suggestion for the restoration of rights

245

without attaching evidentiary support. The court shall

246

immediately set a hearing if no evidentiary support is attached

247

to inquire of the petitioner and guardian advocate as to the

248

reason and enter such orders as are appropriate to secure the

249

required documents. The person with a disability and the person's

250

attorney shall be provided notice of the hearing.

251

     (a) Within 3 days after the filing of the suggestion,

252

counsel shall be appointed for the person with a developmental

253

disability as set forth in subsection (5).

254

     (b) The clerk of the court shall immediately send notice of

255

the filing of the suggestion to the person with a developmental

256

disability, the guardian advocate, the attorney for the person

257

with a developmental disability, the attorney for the guardian

258

advocate, if any, and any other interested person designated by

259

the court. Formal notice shall be served on the guardian

260

advocate. Informal notice may be served on other persons. Notice

261

need not be served on the person who filed the suggestion.

262

     (c) Any objections to the suggestion must be filed within

263

20 days after service of the notice. If an objection is timely

264

filed, or if the evidentiary support suggests that restoration of

265

rights is not appropriate, the court shall set the matter for

266

hearing. The hearing shall be conducted as set forth in s.

267

744.1095. The court, at the hearing, shall consider all reports

268

and testimony relevant to the person's decisionmaking abilities

269

at the hearing, including, but not limited to, the person's

270

current individual family plan or individual support plan, the

271

individual education plan, and other professional reports that

272

document the condition and needs of the person.

273

     (d) Notice of the hearing and copies of the objections

274

shall be served upon the person with a developmental disability,

275

the attorney for the person with a developmental disability, the

276

guardian advocate, the attorney for the guardian advocate, the

277

next of kin of the person with a developmental disability, and

278

any other interested person as directed by the court.

279

     (e) If no objections are filed and the court is satisfied

280

with the evidentiary support for restoration, the court shall

281

enter an order of restoration of rights which were delegated to a

282

guardian advocate and which the person with a developmental

283

disability may now exercise.

284

     (f) At the conclusion of a hearing, the court shall enter

285

an order denying the suggestion or restoring all or some of the

286

rights that were delegated to the guardian advocate. If only some

287

rights are restored to the person with a developmental

288

disability, the court shall enter amended letters of guardian

289

advocacy.

290

     (g) If only some rights are restored to the person with a

291

developmental disability, the order must state which rights are

292

restored and amended letters of guardian advocacy shall be issued

293

by the court. The guardian advocate shall amend the current plan

294

as required under chapter 744 if personal rights are restored to

295

the person with a developmental disability. The guardian advocate

296

shall file a final accounting as required under chapter 744 if

297

all property rights are restored to the person with a

298

developmental disability. The guardian advocate must file the

299

amended plan or final accounting within 60 days after the order

300

restoring rights and amended letters of guardian advocacy are

301

issued. A copy of the reports shall be served upon the person

302

with a developmental disability and the attorney for the person

303

with a developmental disability.

304

     Section 2.  Paragraph (h) of subsection (3) of section

305

393.13, Florida Statutes, is amended to read:

306

     393.13  Treatment of persons with developmental

307

disabilities.--

308

     (3)  RIGHTS OF ALL PERSONS WITH DEVELOPMENTAL

309

DISABILITIES.--The rights described in this subsection shall

310

apply to all persons with developmental disabilities, whether or

311

not such persons are clients of the agency.

312

     (h)  Persons with developmental disabilities shall have a

313

right to consent to or refuse treatment, subject to the powers of

314

a guardian advocate appointed pursuant to s. 393.12 or a guardian

315

appointed pursuant to provisions of s. 393.12(2)(a) or chapter

316

744.

317

     Section 3.  This act shall take effect July 1, 2008.

318

319

================ T I T L E  A M E N D M E N T ================

320

And the title is amended as follows:

321

     Delete everything before the enacting clause

322

and insert:

323

A bill to be entitled

324

An act relating to guardian advocates for persons with

325

developmental disabilities; amending s. 393.12, F.S.;

326

requiring the court to conduct determination of incapacity

327

of persons with developmental disabilities and appointment

328

of guardian advocates in separate proceedings; revising

329

conditions relating to venue for appointment of guardian

330

advocates; providing that the guardian advocate need not

331

be represented by an attorney unless required by the court

332

or the guardian advocate is delegated certain rights

333

regarding property; limiting applicability to certain

334

proceedings relating to appointment and supervision of

335

guardian advocates; requiring the petition to include the

336

relationship of the proposed guardian advocate to certain

337

providers; modifying the persons to whom a notice of the

338

filing of the petition must be given to include next of

339

kin, the health care surrogate designated to execute an

340

advance directive, and the agent under durable power of

341

attorney; establishing a timeframe for appointment of

342

counsel and modifying who may be appointed as counsel to a

343

person with a developmental disability; providing

344

conditions for the court to appoint attorneys; requiring

345

court proceedings and orders to consider advance

346

directives for health care and durable powers of attorney;

347

requiring the court's order to provide the name and

348

reasons for the selection of the guardian advocate;

349

providing a process for restoration of rights for the

350

person with a developmental disability; providing for the

351

petitioner to submit evidentiary support to the court;

352

providing for a hearing if no evidentiary support is

353

available; amending s. 393.13, F.S.; conforming a cross-

354

reference; providing an effective date.

4/21/2008  5:27:00 PM     4-08132-08